When Can a Minor Be Tried as an Adult in Alaska? Mandatory vs. Discretionary Waivers
In Alaska, 16 or 17-year-olds accused of certain serious felonies are automatically prosecuted as adults under Alaska Stat. § 47.12.030. For other offenses, judges may use a discretionary waiver based on the child's amenability to treatment.
The juvenile justice system in Alaska is built on the philosophy of rehabilitation rather than punishment. However, when a minor commits a particularly severe crime, the state may decide that the juvenile system is no longer appropriate. If your child is facing charges in Anchorage, Palmer, or Kenai that could move them to adult court, the stakes are incredibly high. Adult court brings the possibility of prison time, public criminal records, and a lifetime of collateral consequences.
Understanding the legal mechanisms that allow a minor to be tried as an adult is crucial for any parent facing this nightmare scenario. In Alaska, this process is known as a "waiver of jurisdiction." There are two primary types of waivers: automatic (mandatory) and discretionary. Securing an experienced criminal defense lawyer from our US Lawyer Catalog immediately is the best step you can take to fight for your child's future.
Crimes That Trigger Automatic Adult Prosecution in Alaska
Some crimes are considered so severe that the Alaska legislature has removed the juvenile court's jurisdiction entirely. This is governed by Alaska Stat. § 47.12.030. If a minor is 16 or 17 years old at the time of the alleged offense, they will automatically face adult prosecution if charged with:
- Murder in the first or second degree.
- An unclassified or Class A felony against a person (such as severe assault or sexual assault).
- First-degree arson.
- First-degree weapons misconduct under Alaska Stat. § 11.61.190(a)(1) or Alaska Stat. § 11.61.190(a)(2) (discharging a firearm creating a substantial risk of physical injury).
- A Class B felony against a person involving a deadly weapon, if the minor has a prior adjudication for an offense involving a deadly weapon against a person.
In these situations, the minor is bypassed by the Division of Juvenile Justice (DJJ) entirely and is charged directly in the Alaska Superior Court, Anchorage as an adult. There is no hearing to determine if they should be in adult court; it happens automatically based on the charge and their age.
The Discretionary Waiver Hearing: Burden of Proof
If the crime does not meet the strict criteria for an automatic waiver, but the state still believes the minor should be treated as an adult, the prosecutor can request a discretionary waiver under Alaska Stat. § 47.12.100. This involves a high-stakes hearing before a juvenile court judge.
During this hearing, the burden of proof generally rests on the state prosecutor to prove that the minor is not amenable to treatment within the juvenile system before turning 20 years old. However, under Alaska Stat. § 47.12.100(c)(2), if the waiver petition is based on an unclassified felony or Class A felony against a person, the minor is rebuttably presumed not to be amenable to treatment, and the burden shifts to the defense to prove amenability.
How 'Amenability to Treatment' Keeps Cases in Juvenile Court
The core of a discretionary waiver hearing is the concept of "amenability to treatment." To keep the case in juvenile court, a defense lawyer will present evidence showing that the child can be rehabilitated. The judge considers several statutory factors, including:
| Statutory Factor | How the Defense Fights Back |
|---|---|
| Seriousness of the Offense | Providing context, showing lack of malice, or highlighting peer pressure. |
| Minor's Prior Record | Emphasizing a clean record or showing that past interventions were flawed. |
| Sophistication and Maturity | Using psychological evaluations to show immaturity or developmental delays. |
| Protecting the Public | Proposing intensive, secure treatment plans within DJJ facilities. |
A skilled attorney will often bring in expert witnesses, such as adolescent psychologists, to testify that the minor's brain is still developing and that they are highly likely to respond positively to DJJ programs.
Consequences of Getting an Adult Conviction as a Teenager
The ramifications of a minor being convicted in adult court in Alaska are devastating. Unlike juvenile records, which are largely confidential and sealed from the public, adult felony convictions are public records accessible to anyone.
While waived minors held in pre-trial custody must generally be detained in a juvenile facility (DJJ youth center) with sight and sound separation from adult inmates under Alaska Stat. § 47.12.105(a) until reaching age 18, an adult conviction means they face adult sentencing and will eventually serve time in an adult correctional facility under the Department of Corrections. Furthermore, they will face lifelong barriers to finding employment, securing housing, passing background checks, and even applying for student loans. They also lose fundamental rights, such as the right to own a firearm and the right to vote while incarcerated.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can a 15-year-old be tried as an adult in Alaska?
Automatic waivers only apply to minors who are 16 or 17. However, under Alaska Stat. § 47.12.100, a prosecutor can seek a discretionary waiver to adult court for a minor of any age if the circumstances are deemed severe enough and the judge approves.
What happens if the automatic waiver charge is later reduced?
If a minor is automatically waived for a severe charge (like a Class A felony), but the jury convicts them of a lesser offense that does not fall under the automatic waiver statute, the judge may have the discretion to sentence them as a juvenile.
Do adult courts have to sentence minors to adult prison?
If convicted as an adult, the minor faces adult sentencing guidelines. However, under Alaska Stat. § 47.12.105(a) and federal JJDPA standards, prior to sentencing or reaching age 18, a waived minor held in custody must be detained in a secure juvenile facility (DJJ youth center) rather than an adult prison, absent extraordinary judicial findings.
Can we appeal a judge's decision to waive my child to adult court?
Yes, your attorney can appeal a discretionary waiver decision. However, this is a complex legal process that requires demonstrating that the judge abused their discretion in applying the statutory factors.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!