Litigating the Florida Elective Share: When Stepchildren and a Surviving Spouse Clash
Under Florida law, you cannot completely disinherit a surviving spouse. Regardless of what the will says, a widow or widower is generally entitled to claim 30% of the 'elective estate,' which includes both probate and many non-probate assets.
Blended families are incredibly common in Florida. However, when a parent passes away, the dynamic between a surviving spouse (the stepparent) and the deceased's adult children can quickly turn toxic, especially when significant money is on the line. In many cases, a deceased parent may try to leave everything to their children from a prior marriage, effectively cutting out their current spouse. Florida law steps in to prevent this through a mechanism called the 'Elective Share.' This legal right frequently triggers massive probate litigation in cities like Fort Lauderdale and Clearwater. This guide explains how the elective share is calculated, how stepchildren can fight back against fraud, and how prenuptial agreements play a critical role in the courtroom.
Calculating the 30% Elective Estate (Including Non-Probate Assets)
In Florida, a surviving spouse has the absolute right to claim the elective share, which is equal to 30% of the elective estate, according to Fla. Stat. § 732.2065. The most shocking realization for stepchildren is that the 'elective estate' is much larger than just the assets going through probate. Under Fla. Stat. § 732.2035, the elective estate includes almost everything the deceased owned. This includes pay-on-death bank accounts, jointly owned real estate, revocable living trusts, and even the cash surrender value of life insurance policies. The surviving spouse files an Form Non-Numbered, Florida, Circuit Court, Election to Take Elective Share pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 732.2135 to freeze the distribution of these assets until their 30% cut is precisely calculated.
Disputing the Valuation of Complex Assets (Businesses, Real Estate)
Once the spouse makes the election, the battle over 'valuation' begins. Thirty percent of $1 million is very different from 30% of $5 million. In courts like the Broward County Circuit Court, Probate Division, Fort Lauderdale, litigation often centers around how much a family business or a piece of waterfront real estate is actually worth.
The surviving spouse's attorneys will hire appraisers to argue the business is worth a fortune to maximize their 30% payout. Conversely, the stepchildren (often the ones running the business) will hire their own experts to argue the business is worth very little. A judge will ultimately have to listen to expert testimony from both sides to determine the true fair market value of the elective estate.
How Stepchildren Can Fight Fraudulent Asset Transfers
Sometimes, disputes arise over assets transferred shortly before death to alter the elective estate. Under Fla. Stat. § 732.2035(5) and Fla. Stat. § 732.2035(9), Florida law explicitly pulls revocable transfers and certain substantial transfers made within one year of death back into the elective estate calculation. While stepchildren often challenge the inclusion of trust assets, the court in In re Estate of Magee, 988 So. 2d 1 (FL District Court of Appeal 2007) upheld that subjecting revocable trust assets to the elective share is fully constitutional. If a party deliberately concealed assets or engaged in fraudulent transfers, probate litigators can seek court intervention to properly account for all property under Florida's statutory framework.
Challenging the Validity of a Prenuptial Agreement in Probate Court
The single most effective way to block a surviving spouse from claiming the 30% elective share is a valid prenuptial or postnuptial agreement. Under Fla. Stat. § 732.702, a spouse can legally waive their right to the elective share. If stepchildren present a prenup to the Pinellas County Circuit Court, Probate Division, Clearwater, the spouse gets nothing beyond what the will dictates.
However, surviving spouses frequently file lawsuits claiming the prenup is invalid. They may argue they were forced to sign it under duress, or that the deceased hid millions of dollars in assets when the agreement was signed. Litigating the validity of a 20-year-old prenup in probate court is one of the most complex and aggressive forms of estate litigation in Florida.
How Much Does it Cost?
Elective share litigation is high-stakes and highly expensive. The initial court filing fees are generally nominal (around $400 to open the probate case), but this type of litigation relies heavily on forensic accountants and business appraisers, who can charge $10,000 to $25,000 for complex estate valuations. Probate litigators typically charge between $350 and $650 per hour. In many cases, if the spouse is successful, their attorney's fees can be ordered to be paid out of the estate itself, effectively making the stepchildren pay for the spouse's lawsuit.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Filing the election itself is quick; the spouse generally has 6 months from the time they receive a Notice of Administration to file the form. However, fighting over the asset valuations or the validity of a prenuptial agreement can tie up a Florida estate for 18 months to over 3 years. Until the judge determines exactly what 30% amounts to, the stepchildren usually cannot receive their inheritances.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does the surviving spouse get to pick which assets make up their 30%?
No. Florida law provides a strict priority of assets used to satisfy the elective share. The court first looks to assets the spouse already received (like life insurance or joint accounts), and then pulls from the rest of the probate estate if a shortfall exists.
What happens if the deceased spouse lived in another state?
The Florida elective share generally only applies if the deceased was legally domiciled (a permanent resident) in Florida at the time of their death. If they were just 'snowbirds', the laws of their home state usually apply to their personal property.
Can a spouse claim the elective share AND homestead rights?
Yes. The elective share is in addition to other statutory protections like the Florida homestead exemption, exempt personal property (like two vehicles), and a family allowance. A surviving spouse can claim all of these simultaneously.
What if a will says 'I leave my spouse $1 and nothing more'?
In Florida, you cannot write your spouse out of a will without a valid waiver like a prenup. If you leave them $1, they will simply file for the elective share and the judge will grant them 30% of the entire estate regardless of your written wishes.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!