How to Resolve Rural Fence Disputes Using Township Fence Viewers in Iowa

In rural Iowa, good fences make good neighbors, but disagreements over who pays for a property line fence can quickly turn friendly farmers into fierce adversaries. Whether you own rolling pastures in Story County or crop fields near Cedar Rapids, state law provides a highly specific mechanism for resolving these disputes without immediately filing a massive lawsuit. The process relies on local township trustees who step in as statutory 'Fence Viewers.' Navigating this system requires a solid understanding of agricultural law, and we highly recommend browsing our directory to hire a local Iowa attorney who can present your case effectively.

Step-by-Step Process for Fence Disputes in Iowa

When communication breaks down, Iowa Code § 359A.1A allows any landowner to formally request that a boundary fence be erected and maintained. Here is the step-by-step path to legally enforce this requirement.

Step 1: The Written Request

Before involving the government, you must make a formal, written demand to your neighbor asking them to construct or maintain their portion of the partition fence. This should be sent via certified mail so you have proof of delivery. If the neighbor ignores the request or refuses, you may proceed to the next step.

Step 2: Contacting the Township Clerk

If the neighbor refuses, you must file a written request with the clerk of your local township. The clerk will then notify the Township Trustees, who officially act as the 'Fence Viewers.' Pursuant to Iowa Code § 359A.3, the township clerk will serve a mandatory five days' written notice on all adjoining landowners, setting a specific date and time for the trustees to visit the property line.

Step 3: The Fence Viewer Hearing

On the scheduled date, the trustees will physically inspect the boundary line. Both landowners have the right to be present, present evidence, and argue their side. The trustees will determine if a fence is necessary, what type of fence must be built, and which portion each landowner is legally responsible for building and maintaining.

Step 4: The Official Order

Following the inspection, the trustees will issue a written order. This document dictates exactly what must be done and provides a strict deadline (often 30 to 60 days). The order is legally binding. If your neighbor fails to build their assigned portion within the timeframe, you are legally permitted to build it for them and then sue them for the costs, which can be assessed as a property tax lien.

The Customary 'Right-Hand Rule'

When determining who builds which part of the fence, Iowa Fence Viewers often rely on the traditional 'Right-Hand Rule.' Imagine standing on your property, directly facing your neighbor's land. Under this custom, you are responsible for building and maintaining the half of the fence that extends to your right, while your neighbor is responsible for the half that extends to your left. While Iowa Code § 359A.4 does not strictly mandate the right-hand rule, it is the most common method trustees use to apportion costs fairly.

Livestock Fencing Requirements: Cattle vs. Hogs

Not all fences are created equal in the eyes of Iowa law. The type of livestock you or your neighbor own dictates the legal standard for the fence. A standard legal fence generally consists of three barbed wires securely fastened to posts. However, if a landowner is raising smaller livestock, stricter rules apply.

Under Iowa Code § 359A.21, if a property owner keeps sheep or hogs, the partition fence must be made 'tight.' A tight fence typically requires woven wire at the bottom to prevent smaller animals from rooting underneath. If only one neighbor owns hogs, the trustees must carefully apportion the extra cost of the tight fence, often requiring the hog owner to pay for the upgraded woven wire while splitting the cost of the standard posts and barbed wire.

How Much Does it Cost in Iowa?

Disputing a fence is not free. You must pay the Township Trustees for their time. Currently, Iowa law allows trustees to charge an hourly or daily rate for their services as Fence Viewers. This rate is set by the county, but it generally ranges from $15 to $40 per hour, per trustee, plus mileage. These administrative costs are usually split evenly between the two neighbors, though the viewers have the discretion to assign the costs to one party.

How Long Does the Process Take?

From the moment you mail your initial request, you should expect the process to take at least 2 to 3 months. Scheduling the trustees often takes 2 to 4 weeks. Once the order is issued, the losing neighbor is usually given 30 to 60 days to complete the construction. If they fail to do so, the timeline extends as you must build it yourself and seek reimbursement through the courts.

Appealing a Fence Viewer's Decision to the District Court

If you disagree with the decision made by the Township Trustees, you do not have to simply accept it. Under Iowa Code § 359A.23, any party has exactly 20 days from the date the order is issued to file a formal appeal. The appeal must be filed with the local district court, such as the Iowa District Court for Boone County, Boone or the Iowa District Court for Linn County, Cedar Rapids.

When you appeal, the matter proceeds in the district court as an ordinary action at law, where it stands for trial as in other civil cases rather than an equitable de novo proceeding. On further appeal, judicial review is strictly for the correction of errors at law. Prominent cases like Gravert v. Nebergall, 539 N.W.2d 184 (IA Supreme Court 1995) show that courts closely scrutinize whether the trustees' order adhered to statutory authority and whether costs were lawfully apportioned. Having an attorney is absolutely vital at this appellate stage.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)