Incompatibility vs. Fault-Based Divorce in Kansas: Which Should You Choose?
Kansas allows both no-fault (incompatibility) and fault-based divorces. However, 99% of couples choose incompatibility because proving fault rarely changes property division or alimony, but it greatly increases legal costs.
Understanding Grounds for Divorce in Kansas
When you file for divorce in Kansas, you must state a legal reason, known as the grounds for divorce. The state gives you three choices under Kan. Stat. Ann. § 23-2701: incompatibility, failure to perform a marital duty, or incompatibility by reason of mental illness. Incompatibility is a no-fault ground, meaning neither spouse is legally blamed for the breakdown of the marriage. The other two are fault-based grounds, requiring you to prove that your spouse did something wrong or suffers from a severe, institutionalized mental condition.
For couples in Wichita, Kansas City, and Topeka, deciding which ground to plead is a crucial first step. Many people who have been cheated on want to file for fault to get "justice" in court. However, the legal reality in Kansas is that proving bad behavior rarely results in a larger financial payout. Navigating this emotional and legal maze is much easier with the help of a qualified local attorney, which you can find through our directory.
Step-by-Step Analysis of Divorce Grounds in Kansas
When deciding how to file your Form Petition for Divorce, Kansas, Judicial Council, Petition for Divorce, you need to understand how the local district courts, such as the Sedgwick County District Court, Wichita, actually handle these cases.
Why 99% of Kansans Choose Incompatibility
Incompatibility simply means that you and your spouse can no longer get along, and the marriage is beyond repair. You do not need to prove cheating, abuse, or neglect. By choosing this no-fault route, you streamline the legal process. You do not have to call witnesses to testify about your spouse's bad behavior, which keeps your private life out of the public record. More importantly, it keeps your attorney fees down because you are not spending billable hours trying to prove allegations that the judge ultimately will not use to divide your bank accounts.
When Adultery Affects Property Division
Kansas courts are guided by the precedent set in cases like In re Marriage of Sommers, 246 Kan. 652 (KS Supreme Court 1990). In the Sommers case, the Kansas Supreme Court firmly established that marital fault (like adultery) should generally not be considered when dividing property or awarding alimony. A judge will not give you the house just because your spouse cheated. However, there is one major exception: "dissipation of assets." If your spouse spent $20,000 of marital money on lavish vacations and gifts for their affair partner, the court may order them to reimburse the marital estate for that specific wasted money.
Proving Severe Mental Illness in Court
Filing for divorce on the grounds of mental illness is exceedingly rare and difficult in Kansas. Under Kan. Stat. Ann. § 23-2701(b), you cannot just claim your spouse is depressed or narcissistic. You must prove they have a severe mental illness that requires confinement in an institution. Furthermore, the court will appoint a guardian ad litem to protect the incapacitated spouse's rights, and you will need testimony from multiple medical professionals. Unless this specific extreme situation applies, it is almost always faster and cheaper to file under simple incompatibility.
How Much Does it Cost in Kansas?
Your choice of grounds directly impacts how much your divorce will cost. Preparing for a trial to prove fault is very expensive.
| Type of Divorce Strategy | Estimated Legal Cost (USD) |
|---|---|
| Uncontested Incompatibility | $1,500 - $3,000 |
| Contested Incompatibility | $3,500 - $7,000 |
| Fault-Based Litigation (Trial) | $10,000 - $25,000+ |
| Court Filing Fees | $195 - $198 |
How Long Does the Process Take?
A standard no-fault divorce based on incompatibility can be finalized shortly after the mandatory 60-day waiting period, often taking just 2 to 4 months if both sides cooperate. If you choose to pursue a fault-based divorce-meaning you allege failure to perform a marital duty-your spouse will likely fight back to clear their name. This requires the discovery of text messages, financial audits, and depositions. A fault-based trial at the Johnson County District Court, Olathe can drag the process out to 12 to 18 months or longer.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Will I get more alimony if my spouse cheated?
Generally, no. Under Kansas case law, marital fault is not a factor used to calculate spousal maintenance (alimony). Alimony is based on financial need and the ability to pay.
Can my spouse stop the divorce by refusing to sign?
No. Because Kansas allows for no-fault divorce based on incompatibility, your spouse cannot force you to stay married. If they refuse to participate, the judge can grant a default judgment.
Is emotional abuse considered 'failure to perform a marital duty'?
It can be, but pleading this requires a trial to prove the abuse occurred. Most attorneys advise victims to file under incompatibility while using the evidence of abuse separately to argue for restricted child custody.
Do I need proof to file for incompatibility?
No. You simply testify that you and your spouse are incompatible and that the marriage cannot be saved. No physical proof or witnesses are required.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!