When Can a Minor Be Tried as an Adult in Maine? Fighting Bind-Over Motions

The juvenile justice system is built on the belief that children can be rehabilitated. However, when a minor commits a highly severe crime, the state of Maine can attempt to transfer the case to the adult criminal justice system. This process is known as a "bind-over." If a youth is bound over to adult court, they lose all the privacy protections and rehabilitative focus of the juvenile system, facing the terrifying reality of adult prison time.

Fighting a bind-over motion is arguably the most critical stage in a serious juvenile case. It requires aggressive defense strategies and expert witness testimonies. Families facing this nightmare should urgently utilize our USA Lawyers Directory to find a top-tier criminal defense attorney in Maine who specializes in complex juvenile bind-over hearings.

Maine's Age Limits and Criteria for Adult Jurisdiction

The rules governing when a juvenile can be tried as an adult are rigidly outlined in 15 M.R.S. § 3101. Unlike some states that have an automatic transfer for certain crimes based on age alone, Maine requires a judicial hearing. The prosecutor must officially file a motion to bind the juvenile over to the Superior Court.

The law states that for a bind-over to be considered, the juvenile must be charged with murder or a Class A, Class B, or Class C crime (which includes severe offenses like aggravated assault, robbery, or gross sexual assault). The landmark case State v. Rosado, 669 A.2d 180 (ME Supreme Judicial Court 1996) established the heavy burden placed on the state. The judge must determine not just if there is probable cause that the child committed the crime, but whether the juvenile system is entirely incapable of rehabilitating the youth before they age out of the system.

Step-by-Step Bind-Over Hearing Process

A bind-over hearing is essentially a mini-trial held in the District Court before the case is potentially sent to the Superior Court, such as the Penobscot County Superior Court, Bangor or the York County Superior Court, Biddeford.

Step 1: The Probable Cause Phase

The bind-over hearing is split into two parts. First, the District Attorney must prove that there is probable cause to believe the juvenile committed the specific felony offense. The defense attorney can cross-examine police officers and witnesses. If the judge finds no probable cause, the bind-over motion is denied, and the charge may be dismissed or reduced.

Step 2: The Amenability to Rehabilitation Phase

If probable cause is found, the court moves to the second phase: deciding if the child should be tried as an adult. The judge evaluates the child's age, criminal history, emotional maturity, and the nature of the offense. This is where your defense attorney must prove that the minor can be saved. The state will argue that the public's safety requires an adult sentence.

Step 3: The Role of Psychological Evaluations

This is the most crucial part of the defense. Your lawyer will hire a forensic psychologist to evaluate the child. The psychologist will submit a detailed report to the court assessing the minor's brain development, trauma history, and responsiveness to treatment. If an expert testifies that the child has a high capacity for change and would benefit from the programs at the Long Creek Youth Development Center, South Portland rather than an adult prison, the judge is much more likely to keep the case in juvenile court.

Step 4: Defense Strategies During Bind-Over Hearings

A strong defense strategy focuses heavily on the timeline. The juvenile system in Maine only holds jurisdiction until the youth turns 21. If the youth is 17 at the time of the offense, the state will argue there is not enough time (only 4 years) to rehabilitate them. Your attorney's strategy must involve presenting a concrete, intensive treatment plan that proves rehabilitation can be achieved within the remaining timeframe of juvenile jurisdiction.

Costs of Defending a Bind-Over Motion

Defending against an adult transfer is incredibly labor-intensive and requires specialized experts, making it highly expensive.

Timeline for Bind-Over Proceedings

Once a juvenile is arrested for a severe felony, the District Attorney will usually file a bind-over motion within the first 30 days. The actual bind-over hearing may not occur for 3 to 6 months while both sides conduct psychological evaluations and gather evidence. If the judge grants the motion, the case is immediately transferred to the Superior Court for adult arraignment. If denied, the case remains in the juvenile court for a standard adjudication hearing.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)