How Not Wearing a Helmet Affects Your Motorcycle Accident Settlement in Maine
Adult riders over the age of 18 with a standard motorcycle license are not legally required to wear a helmet in Maine. However, if you suffer a head injury in a crash, insurance companies will fiercely argue that your choice not to wear a helmet reduces your right to full financial compensation.
Maine is one of several states that values individual liberty when it comes to motorcycle safety gear. The state allows most adult riders to experience the open road without a helmet. Unfortunately, this freedom can become a massive legal liability if you are struck by a negligent driver. Even if a drunk or distracted driver completely causes the collision, their insurance company will immediately focus on your lack of a helmet to minimize what they have to pay you. They will argue that you failed to protect yourself and are therefore responsible for your own head injuries.
Fighting this insurance tactic requires a deep understanding of Maine's comparative negligence laws and medical forensics. Because a severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars in lifetime medical care, you cannot afford to let an insurance adjuster arbitrarily slash your settlement. We highly urge you to search our directory to find an experienced Maine motorcycle accident lawyer who knows how to defeat the 'helmet defense' in court.
Maine's Specific Motorcycle Helmet Laws
To understand your rights, you must first verify whether you were legally required to wear a helmet at the time of the crash. Maine does not have a universal helmet law, but it has strict exemptions. Under Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 29-A, § 2083, protective headgear is absolutely mandatory for specific classes of riders. The Maine Bureau of Motor Vehicles, Augusta enforces these rules strictly. If you fall into one of the mandatory categories and ride without a helmet, you can be cited by law enforcement.
Minors and Permit Holders: Legal Consequences
The state requires three specific groups of people to wear a federally approved DOT helmet: riders under 18 years of age (including passengers), individuals operating under a learner's permit, and newly licensed riders who are within their first year of completing a motorcycle safety course and obtaining their endorsement. If you belong to one of these groups and are injured while riding without a helmet, the insurance company has a very strong legal argument. They will claim 'negligence per se'-meaning you violated a safety statute-making it significantly harder for your attorney to secure full compensation for any head or neck injuries.
How Insurance Companies Weaponize Your Helmet Status
Even if you are an experienced adult rider who is legally permitted to ride bareheaded, insurance adjusters will try to weaponize your helmet status against you.
Adult Riders Over 18: Beating the Assumption of Risk Defense
For adults legally riding without a helmet, defense attorneys often raise the 'assumption of risk' or 'failure to mitigate damages' arguments. They suggest that by choosing not to wear a helmet, you accepted the risk of a severe head injury. To beat this defense, your lawyer will point out that exercising your legal right under Maine law cannot automatically constitute negligence. Furthermore, the defense must medically prove that a helmet would have actually prevented the specific injury you suffered. Your attorney will likely rely on biomechanical experts and precedents regarding comparative fault to challenge the insurance company's assumptions in courts like the York County Superior Court, Biddeford.
Non-Head Injuries vs. Head Injuries in Helmetless Crashes
It is vital to separate your injuries. A helmet only protects your skull and brain. If a distracted driver T-bones your motorcycle and shatters your leg, causes internal bleeding, or breaks your ribs, your lack of a helmet is completely legally and medically irrelevant to those specific injuries. An insurance adjuster is not allowed to reduce your compensation for a broken femur simply because your head was unprotected. A skilled personal injury attorney will aggressively shut down any attempt to use the helmet defense to devalue non-head and non-neck injuries.
Costs and Timelines for Resolving the Claim
Motorcycle accident attorneys in Maine work on a contingency fee, usually taking 33% of the final settlement. Overcoming the helmet defense requires spending money on medical experts and accident reconstructionists, which your lawyer will advance on your behalf. Because these cases often involve severe brain injuries, they cannot be rushed. You must reach 'Maximum Medical Improvement' (MMI) before your lawyer can accurately calculate your lifetime medical costs. Consequently, resolving a complex brain injury claim where the helmet defense is utilized typically takes between 12 to 24 months of aggressive litigation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I still sue if I was legally required to wear a helmet and wasn't?
Yes, you can still file a claim. However, because Maine follows a 50% modified comparative fault rule, if a jury decides that your failure to wear a legally required helmet makes you 50% or more responsible for your head injuries, you will be barred from recovering compensation for those specific injuries.
Will a novelty helmet count as protective headgear?
No. Maine law specifically requires helmets that meet standard federal DOT (Department of Transportation) safety regulations. Thin plastic 'novelty' or 'skull cap' helmets do not provide legal or physical protection.
How does the insurance company know if I was wearing a helmet?
The responding police officer will document whether you were wearing a helmet on the official traffic crash report. Additionally, paramedics and emergency room doctors frequently note the presence or absence of a helmet in your initial medical records.
Do passengers have the same helmet rules as the driver?
Yes. If the passenger is under 18 years old, they must wear a helmet. Furthermore, if the operator is legally required to wear a helmet (such as a permit holder), they are prohibited from carrying passengers at all.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!