Suing a Title Company for Negligence and Missed Defects in Maine
If a Maine title company negligently misses a lien or boundary defect, you may have grounds to sue for breach of contract or professional negligence. However, property owners must act swiftly, as Maine enforces a strict 6-year statute of limitations for these civil lawsuits.
Buying real estate in Maine involves relying heavily on the expertise of professionals. You expect the title examiner to dig through county registries and uncover any hidden mortgages, restrictive covenants, or tax liens before you sign the closing papers. When they fail to do so, the consequences can be financially devastating. Discovering that a previous owner's massive tax debt is now attached to your home can stall renovations, prevent a future sale, and put your property at risk of foreclosure.
When a title company makes a catastrophic error, you are not entirely out of luck. Under Maine law, you have the right to seek financial restitution. However, suing a title abstractor, agent, or insurance underwriter involves complex litigation. The defense will fiercely argue that their liability is limited to the exact wording of the insurance policy. Retaining a seasoned real estate litigator from our Maine directory is critical to building a strong case and proving that the company failed in its legal duties.
Breach of Contract vs. Tort Claims
When you file a lawsuit against a title entity in a venue like the Kennebec County Superior Court, Augusta, your lawyer will generally pursue two distinct legal theories: Breach of Contract and Professional Negligence (a tort claim).
| Legal Claim | Basis of the Lawsuit in Maine |
|---|---|
| Breach of Contract | This claim targets the title insurance underwriter. It argues that the insurer violated the specific terms of the title insurance policy by refusing to pay a valid claim or failing to clear a covered defect. Your damages are strictly limited to the policy amount. |
| Professional Negligence (Tort) | This claim often targets the local title abstractor or attorney who performed the title search. It argues they breached their professional duty of care by failing to discover a defect that a reasonably competent examiner would have found in the public records. |
Under Maine's general statute of limitations, 14 M.R.S. § 752, you generally have six years to file a civil lawsuit for breach of contract and professional negligence. However, determining when that clock begins is critical. While ordinary professional negligence actions accrue on the date of the act or omission, Maine provides a crucial discovery rule under 14 M.R.S. § 753-B(2): if the claim involves an attorney or title examiner rendering a real estate title opinion, the six-year statute of limitations begins on the date the negligence is discovered, subject to a 20-year statute of repose. Failing to file within the applicable statutory window will result in your claim being permanently dismissed.
Proving Damages and Diminution of Property Value
To win a lawsuit against a title company, you must prove that their mistake caused you actual, quantifiable financial harm. You cannot sue them simply for making a harmless clerical error.
If the missed defect is a monetary lien (like a $50,000 contractor's lien), the damages are relatively straightforward: the cost to pay off the lien and clear the title. However, if the missed defect is an unrecorded conservation easement that prevents you from building a garage, your damages are calculated based on the 'diminution of value.' This requires hiring a certified real estate appraiser to testify regarding how much the property's fair market value has dropped because of the newly discovered restriction. The court will use these expert appraisals to calculate your final compensation.
How Maine Courts View the 'Duty to Defend'
One of the most powerful provisions in a title insurance contract is the 'Duty to Defend.' If a third party sues you over a property defect, your title insurer is contractually obligated to hire a lawyer and defend your title in court. Maine courts interpret this duty very broadly.
In Maine, the duty to defend is triggered if the underlying complaint reveals any potential basis for coverage, even if the claim ultimately proves to be meritless. If a title insurer wrongly refuses to defend you, and you are forced to hire your own attorney to fight the neighbor's lawsuit, you can sue the title company later for breach of the duty to defend. If successful, courts will often force the insurer to reimburse you for all the legal fees you spent defending the property, as seen in broad insurance precedents similar to Penney v. Capitol City Transfer, Inc., 707 A.2d 387 (ME Supreme Judicial Court 1998) regarding defense obligations.
How Much Does it Cost to Sue a Title Company in Maine?
Litigating against large title insurance underwriters requires a significant financial commitment.
- Attorney Fees: Most commercial and real estate litigators in Maine charge hourly rates ranging from $250 to $450 per hour. Complex title litigation can easily cost $15,000 to $40,000+ if the case goes to a full trial.
- Expert Witness Fees: Hiring a professional title abstractor to testify about the standard of care, or an appraiser to prove diminution of value, usually costs $2,000 to $5,000 per expert.
- Court Costs: Filing a civil complaint in a Maine Superior Court requires a standard filing fee of $175, plus minor fees for serving the summons.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Suing a title company is rarely a swift process. Once your lawyer files the complaint, the discovery phase-where both sides demand documents, depose the original title abstractors, and exchange expert reports-can take 9 to 15 months. If the insurance company refuses to offer a fair settlement, getting a trial date on a crowded Maine court docket can push the entire timeline to 18 to 24 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I sue if the title company missed an old zoning violation?
Standard title insurance policies typically exclude zoning laws and municipal building code violations from coverage, meaning you generally cannot successfully sue the title company for missing them unless you purchased a specific zoning endorsement.
Does the title company have to buy the property back from me?
No. While the insurer must compensate you for the diminution of value or pay to cure the defect up to the policy limit, they are not legally obligated to purchase the defective property from you.
What happens if the policy limit is lower than my damages?
Under a breach of contract claim, your recovery is strictly capped at the face value of the title policy (usually the purchase price of the home). However, if you successfully prove professional negligence in tort, you might be able to recover damages beyond the policy limits.
Should I stop paying my mortgage if there is a title defect?
Absolutely not. A title defect does not invalidate your obligation to repay your mortgage loan. Stopping payments will result in the bank foreclosing on the home, creating a much larger legal problem for you.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!