Auto Theft vs. Joyriding: Unauthorized Use of a Vehicle in Maryland
In Maryland, Motor Vehicle Theft is a felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison, while Unauthorized Use (joyriding) is a misdemeanor. Unlike general theft, neither vehicle offense requires the state to prove an intent to permanently deprive the owner.
Being accused of stealing a car in Maryland is a terrifying experience that can lead to severe prison time and a permanent felony record. However, not all instances of taking a vehicle are treated equally under the law. Maryland makes a very distinct separation between a professional car thief who steals a vehicle to sell its parts, and someone who takes a car for a temporary joyride without permission.
Understanding exactly which statute applies to your situation can mean the difference between a minor misdemeanor and a life-altering felony. Because these cases hinge on complex interpretations of your state of mind at the time of the incident, you should browse our directory to find a skilled local Maryland criminal defense attorney to advocate for you in court.
The Core Difference: Intent to Permanently Deprive
While many assume auto theft requires proving an intent to keep the car forever, Maryland law treats vehicle offenses differently. Under Md. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 7-105, the state does not have to prove an intent to permanently deprive the owner; prosecutors only need to establish that you knowingly and willfully took a motor vehicle out of the owner's lawful custody, control, or use without consent. The specific intent to permanently deprive applies to general theft under Md. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 7-104.
Conversely, Unauthorized Use of a Vehicle, commonly called joyriding, is prosecuted under Md. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 7-203. As established in In re Landon G., 214 Md. App. 483 (MD Appellate Court 2013), § 7-105 functions as a felony enhancement of § 7-203, imposing up to 5 years in prison without requiring prosecutors to prove an intent to permanently deprive the owner of the vehicle.
Common Joyriding and Unauthorized Use Scenarios
Many unauthorized use cases do not involve shattered windows or hot-wired ignitions. They frequently stem from misunderstandings or civil disputes.
Failing to Return a Rental Car on Time
If you rent a car at BWI Airport and keep it days or weeks past the return date, the rental agency might report it stolen. While the police may initially investigate it as a felony auto theft, a defense attorney can often argue that it is merely a breach of contract or, at worst, unauthorized use, since there was an initial agreement and no intent to permanently steal the vehicle.
Taking a Roommate's or Family Member's Car
Disputes in households often lead to joyriding charges. If you take your roommate's car without asking to run a quick errand, and they angrily call the police, you could face an unauthorized use charge. However, in courtrooms like the District Court of Maryland for Baltimore County, Towson, lawyers frequently use the defense of implied consent-arguing that past behavior gave you reasonable belief you were allowed to use the car.
Passenger Liability: Did You Know It Was Stolen?
You do not have to be the driver to be charged with unauthorized use. If you are a passenger in a joyridden car, prosecutors can charge you if they can prove you knew the driver did not have permission to use the vehicle. Maryland case law, such as In re Levon A., 361 Md. 626 (MD Supreme Court 2000), frequently explores the necessity of proving a defendant's active participation and knowledge in unauthorized use cases.
Penalties and Fines in Maryland
The penalties diverge significantly based on which charge the state decides to pursue.
| Charge Type | Classification | Maximum Prison Time | Maximum Fine |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motor Vehicle Theft | Felony | 5 Years | $5,000 |
| Unauthorized Use | Misdemeanor | 4 Years | $100 (Minimum $50) |
| Carjacking | Felony | 30 Years | None Specified |
Keep in mind that if force or intimidation is used to take the car from a person, the charge immediately escalates to Carjacking, one of the most severely punished crimes in the state.
How Long Does the Court Process Take?
Misdemeanor unauthorized use cases are typically handled in District Courts and resolve relatively quickly, often within 3 to 6 months. Felony motor vehicle theft cases are elevated to the Circuit Court level, such as the Baltimore City Circuit Court, Baltimore. These felony trials require extensive discovery, witness testimonies, and potential jury selection, pushing the timeline to 8 to 14 months before a final verdict.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can a joyriding charge be dismissed if the owner forgives me?
Once the police are involved and charges are filed, only the state prosecutor has the power to dismiss the case. However, an owner refusing to testify makes the prosecutor's job very difficult and often leads to a dismissal.
What if I genuinely thought I had permission?
An honest and reasonable belief that you had the owner's consent is a complete defense to both auto theft and unauthorized use in Maryland.
Will my license be suspended for unauthorized use?
A conviction for motor vehicle theft or unauthorized use can prompt the Maryland Motor Vehicle Administration (MVA) to suspend or revoke your driving privileges.
Is it theft if I keep the car but send the owner money?
Yes. You cannot unilaterally force someone to sell you their car. Taking the vehicle without permission is illegal, regardless of whether you attempted to compensate them afterward.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!