Court-Ordered DNA Testing in Massachusetts: Who Pays and What Happens if the Mother Refuses?
A Massachusetts Probate and Family Court judge has the authority to compel genetic marker testing to establish paternity. If a mother refuses a court-ordered test, she faces contempt charges, and if a putative father fails to appear, the court may enter a default judgment declaring him the legal father.
Establishing true biological parentage is the foundation of child custody, visitation rights, and child support obligations in Massachusetts. Whether you are a father fighting to see a child you believe is yours, or a mother seeking support from a man denying his responsibilities, scientific evidence is the ultimate decider. Under Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 209C, § 17, the Massachusetts Probate and Family Court has the authority to order mandatory genetic marker testing.
Navigating this process in Boston, Cambridge, or Worcester requires strict adherence to legal procedures. You cannot simply mail a cheek swab to a commercial lab and hand the results to a judge. Court-admissible DNA testing requires chain-of-custody protocols, specific legal filings, and enforcement mechanisms. A dedicated local family attorney from our directory can guide you through the process of filing the correct motions to secure undeniable scientific proof.
How Court-Ordered DNA Testing Works in MA
To initiate a court-ordered test, a party must file Form CJD-106, Massachusetts, Probate and Family Court, Complaint to Establish Parentage. Once the complaint is filed and the other party is served, a judge or magistrate will review the case. If paternity is genuinely in dispute, the court will issue an order directing the mother, the child, and the putative (alleged) father to submit to genetic marker testing at a state-approved facility.
Allocating the Cost of DNA Tests (DOR vs. Private Filings)
A major concern for many individuals is the cost of the test, which generally ranges from $300 to $500. Who pays depends on how the case was brought to court:
- DOR-Initiated Cases: If the mother applies for state assistance or uses the services of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue Child Support Enforcement Division, Worcester, the state will often advance the cost of the DNA test. If the test proves the man is the biological father, the court will typically order him to reimburse the state for the cost of the test.
- Private Filings: If you hire a private attorney to file the paternity complaint, the court generally requires the petitioner (the person asking for the test) to pay the upfront costs. If the results are positive, the petitioner can ask the judge to force the other party to share or reimburse the expenses.
Consequences of a Mother Ignoring a Court Order
Sometimes, a mother refuses to show up for the DNA test to block a father from gaining custody rights. If a judge at the Middlesex Probate and Family Court South, Woburn or another local court orders the test, compliance is mandatory. If the mother fails to appear, the father's attorney can file a Complaint for Contempt. The judge has broad powers to enforce the order, including imposing fines, issuing a bench warrant for the mother's arrest, or entering a default judgment that legally acknowledges the petitioner as the father.
What Happens if the Putative Father Fails to Appear
Conversely, if an alleged father attempts to dodge child support by ignoring a court order for DNA testing, the consequences are severe. In cases analogous to Department of Revenue v. B.P., 412 Mass. 1015 (MA Supreme Judicial Court 1992), Massachusetts courts have established that refusal to submit to testing can result in a default judgment. This means the judge will legally declare the absent man to be the biological father without any DNA proof, resulting in an immediate and enforceable child support order.
Why At-Home Kits Are Inadmissible in Court
Do not waste money on an over-the-counter DNA kit from a pharmacy or online services like Ancestry or 23andMe if you intend to use it in court. Massachusetts rules of evidence strictly require a "chain of custody." This means an independent, neutral third party (a certified lab technician) must verify the photo IDs of all parties, physically take the buccal (cheek) swabs, seal the samples, and document the entire transfer process to the laboratory. At-home kits have zero chain of custody, making it impossible to prove who actually provided the saliva sample, rendering them completely inadmissible for legal purposes.
Legal vs. At-Home DNA Testing
| Feature | Court-Ordered Legal DNA Test | At-Home DNA Test (e.g., 23andMe) |
|---|---|---|
| ID Verification | Strictly required (Government ID + Photos taken) | None; anonymous submission allowed |
| Sample Collection | Collected by a certified professional | Swabbed privately in a bathroom |
| Court Admissibility | 100% Admissible in MA Probate Courts | Inadmissible (hearsay / no chain of custody) |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How accurate are court-ordered DNA tests?
Court-approved genetic marker testing is incredibly accurate. If a man is the father, the probability of paternity will typically be 99.9% or higher. If he is not the father, the result will show a 0% probability.
Can a DNA test be ordered before the baby is born?
While non-invasive prenatal paternity tests exist, Massachusetts family courts generally wait until after the child is born to order standard buccal (cheek) swab DNA testing, as it is safer and far less expensive.
What happens if the mother is married to someone else?
If the mother is married, her husband is the "presumed" legal father under Massachusetts law. Overcoming this presumption requires filing a formal complaint and usually a hearing before a judge will even authorize a DNA test for an outside biological father.
How long does it take to get court-approved DNA results?
Once the cheek swabs are collected at the approved laboratory, it typically takes anywhere from 3 to 10 business days for the official, notarized results to be sent back to the court, the DOR, and your attorney.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!