At What Age Can a Child Choose Which Parent to Live With in Michigan?
In Michigan, there is no magic age where a child can legally choose which parent to live with. While the judge will consider the "reasonable preference" of an older child, the court always makes the final custody decision. If you need to change your custody arrangement, you must file a motion in Circuit Court, which typically requires a $100 filing fee.
A very common myth in Michigan is that once a child turns 12 years old, they can walk into a courtroom, pack their bags, and decide which parent they want to live with. This is completely false. In the state of Michigan, children do not dictate custody orders. The state operates under the Mich. Comp. Laws § 722.21, which mandates that every custody decision must be based on the "best interests of the child." To determine this, judges evaluate 12 specific factors. The preference of the child is only one of these factors, and it never outweighs the others if the child's choice is not safe or healthy.
If your child is expressing a strong desire to live with you, or if your teenager is refusing to go to their other parent's house, you must navigate the Friend of the Court (FOC) system to legally modify your order. Taking matters into your own hands can result in severe legal penalties. We highly recommend browsing our United States Attorney Directory to find a compassionate local family law attorney in Michigan who can help you present your child's wishes to the court legally and effectively.
The 'Reasonable Preference of the Child' Factor
Under Mich. Comp. Laws § 722.23, the court must consider 12 distinct "Best Interest Factors." Factor 'i' is "the reasonable preference of the child, if the court considers the child to be of sufficient age to express preference." The keyword here is reasonable. If a 14-year-old wants to live with their father simply because he has no bedtime rules and buys them video games, a judge will likely disregard that preference. As established in important case law like Pierron v. Pierron, 486 Mich. 81 (MI Supreme Court 2010), the preference must be rooted in maturity and sound reasoning, not a desire to escape parental discipline.
Step-by-Step Process in Michigan
Whether you are in Oakland County, Wayne County, or Kent County, the process for bringing a child's preference to the court's attention follows a strict path.
Step 1: Filing a Motion Regarding Custody
You cannot simply call the judge and say your child wants to move. You must formally file Form FOC 87, Michigan, State Court Administrative Office, Motion Regarding Custody with your local court, such as the Macomb County Circuit Court, Mount Clemens. You must show the judge there has been a "proper cause or change of circumstances" before the court will even agree to look at the current custody order.
Step 2: Friend of the Court (FOC) Investigation
Once you file, the judge will typically refer your case to a local FOC investigator, such as one at the Wayne County Friend of the Court, Detroit. The investigator will interview both parents and, if appropriate, the child. The FOC will then write a detailed recommendation for the judge, noting whether the child's preference is mature and reasonable.
Step 3: In-Camera Interviews with the Judge
Judges hate putting children on the witness stand to testify in front of their parents. Instead, if the judge needs to hear directly from the child, they will conduct an "in-camera interview." This means the child will speak privately with the judge in the judge's chambers (office). The parents and the attorneys are not allowed in the room. The conversation is kept confidential so the child feels safe expressing their true feelings without fear of hurting either parent.
How Teenagers (14-17) Influence Custody
While the court makes the final call, the preferences of older teenagers (ages 14 to 17) carry significantly more weight than those of younger children. A 16-year-old in Grand Rapids or Ann Arbor usually has strong ties to their high school, sports teams, and social circles. If a teenager presents a logical argument to the judge-for example, "I want to live with Mom because her house is closer to my high school, and I need to maintain my GPA for college"-the court is very likely to honor that preference.
What to Do When a Teenager Refuses to Visit
A major crisis for many divorced parents occurs when a teenager simply refuses to get in the car for their scheduled weekend. In Michigan, you cannot just say, "Well, they are 15, I cannot force them." The court order applies to the parents, not the child. If you are the custodial parent, you have an affirmative legal duty to encourage and facilitate parenting time. If you "let" your teenager skip visits without filing a formal motion to change the schedule, the other parent can file a "Show Cause" motion against you for contempt of court, which could result in fines or even jail time. Always file a motion to modify the order rather than ignoring it.
How Much Does it Cost in Michigan?
Modifying a custody order to reflect your child's wishes involves several baseline costs.
- Court Filing Fees: Filing a Motion Regarding Custody in a Michigan Circuit Court generally requires a $100 filing fee.
- FOC Investigation Fees: Some counties charge an administrative fee (around $50 to $100) if a full Friend of the Court investigation is ordered.
- Attorney Fees: Retaining a family law attorney to navigate a contested custody modification usually costs between $2,500 and $5,000 depending on the complexity of the trial.
How Long Does the Process Take?
After filing your motion, securing a hearing date can take 4 to 8 weeks. If the judge orders a full Friend of the Court investigation and an in-camera interview, the process can stretch to 3 to 6 months before a final decision is made. It is crucial to continue following your current custody order during this entire waiting period.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Will my child have to testify in open court?
Almost never. Michigan judges use in-camera (private) interviews to protect children from the emotional trauma of choosing between parents in a public courtroom.
Can a 17-year-old just move out?
Technically, a child is a minor subject to the court's custody orders until they turn 18. However, practically speaking, police and courts are highly reluctant to physically force a 17-year-old to live somewhere against their will, but you should still legally modify the order to protect yourself.
What if the other parent is brainwashing the child?
If a judge or FOC investigator determines that a child's "preference" is actually the result of parental alienation or coaching, the court will completely disregard the child's statement and may penalize the coaching parent.
Does the child get to choose the visitation schedule?
No. While an older teenager's busy schedule (sports, jobs, academics) is heavily considered when crafting a parenting time plan, the judge ultimately sets the legal schedule, not the teenager.
Can my child write a letter to the judge instead?
Generally, judges do not accept informal letters because there is no way to verify that the child wrote it without pressure from a parent. The judge will want to speak to the child directly in an in-camera interview or have the FOC investigator interview them.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!