Suing a Title Insurance Company for Bad Faith in Missouri
If a title insurer wrongfully denies your claim in Missouri, you can sue them for bad faith under the Vexatious Refusal to Pay statute. You may be entitled to recover your property losses, a statutory penalty, and your attorney's fees. Find a Missouri insurance lawyer in our directory today.
When you purchase real estate, buying a title insurance policy is supposed to provide peace of mind. The insurer guarantees that you own the property free and clear of undiscovered liens, easements, or ownership claims. However, when a massive title defect suddenly appears and threatens your ownership, title companies often look for any excuse to deny your claim. If a title insurer in Missouri acts unreasonably or flat-out refuses to defend your property rights, you have the legal right to fight back under strict state insurance laws.
Understanding Title Insurance Denials and the Duty to Defend
Title insurance policies contain two distinct promises: the 'duty to indemnify' (pay for actual financial losses) and the 'duty to defend' (pay for a lawyer if someone sues you over the title). Insurers frequently breach these duties. Here is how specific denial scenarios are aggressively challenged in Missouri courts.
Step 1: Fighting Denials Based on Schedule B Exceptions
Every title policy contains a 'Schedule B' section, which lists specific exceptions that the policy will not cover (e.g., standard utility easements or existing HOA restrictions). When a claim arises, insurers often point to a vaguely worded Schedule B exception and deny coverage. A skilled attorney will heavily scrutinize the title commitment. Under Missouri law, exceptions must be clear and specific. If the insurer tries to use a generic, boiler-plate exception to deny a massive, unexpected lien, your lawyer can file a breach of contract lawsuit in the St. Charles County Circuit Court, St. Charles to force coverage.
Step 2: Failure to Discover Unrecorded Easements
Title companies are paid to conduct exhaustive searches of the county land records. Occasionally, a neighbor will produce an old, unrecorded easement or a deeply buried historical deed claiming they have the right to drive across your land. If the title company's abstractor missed a document that was properly indexed, their failure to discover it is exactly what the policy is supposed to cover. If they deny the claim by arguing the easement was 'obvious' or 'open and notorious' (which often triggers a survey exception), you must litigate to prove the defect was hidden and purely a matter of public record.
Step 3: Refusal to Pay for Legal Defense
If a third party files a quiet title lawsuit against you claiming they own your backyard, your title insurer generally has an absolute duty to hire a lawyer to defend you. The duty to defend is much broader than the duty to pay a claim. If the title company refuses to provide legal counsel, you are forced to pay out-of-pocket to save your land. When you eventually sue the title company for this breach, you can seek reimbursement for all the legal fees you spent defending yourself, plus damages for their bad faith refusal.
Missouri Laws on Insurance Bad Faith: Vexatious Refusal
Missouri does not recognize a standard common-law tort for 'bad faith' against first-party insurers. Instead, the state relies on a powerful, specific statute: Mo. Rev. Stat. § 375.420, known as the Vexatious Refusal to Pay statute. If you can prove that the title company denied your valid claim without reasonable cause or excuse, the court can penalize them severely. Precedents like Dhyne v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co., 188 S.W.3d 454 (MO Supreme Court 2006) outline that a plaintiff must show the insurer's refusal was willful and without reasonable cause as the facts appeared at the time. You may also submit a formal administrative Consumer Complaint online through the official portal of the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, Jefferson City or by downloading a standard complaint form to trigger a state investigation.
| Penalty Type | What You Can Recover Under RSMo 375.420 |
|---|---|
| Base Claim | The actual value of the title defect or lost property value. |
| Statutory Penalty | Up to 20% of the first $1,500 of the loss, plus 10% of the loss exceeding $1,500. |
| Attorney's Fees | The court can order the insurer to pay your lawyer's reasonable fees for having to sue them. |
Legal Costs and Timelines
Taking a massive national title insurance underwriter to court requires strategic financial planning.
- Contingency vs. Hourly: Many real estate litigators charge hourly ($300 - $500/hour) because title cases are highly technical. However, because of the Vexatious Refusal statute allowing the recovery of attorney's fees, some attorneys may take strong cases on a partial contingency basis.
- Court Costs: Filing a civil lawsuit in a Missouri Circuit Court typically costs around $200 in filing fees.
- Timeline: Suing an insurance company is rarely quick. Insurers will file multiple motions to dismiss. You should expect the litigation process to take 12 to 24 months before reaching a trial or a substantial settlement agreement.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the difference between an owner's policy and a lender's policy?
A lender's policy only protects the bank's mortgage investment if the title fails. It provides absolutely zero protection to you, the homeowner. You must have purchased an Owner's Title Policy at closing to file a claim for yourself.
How long do I have to report a title issue to my insurer?
You must report any notice of a title defect or lawsuit to your title insurer immediately. Standard policies require 'prompt notice.' If you wait months to tell them and try to fight the issue yourself first, the insurer will deny the claim based on late notice.
Will the state Department of Insurance force them to pay?
Filing a complaint with the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, Jefferson City can trigger an investigation and put pressure on the insurer, but the Department generally cannot force an insurer to pay a disputed contractual claim. You usually need a court judgment for that.
Can I claim emotional distress against the title company?
Generally, no. Title insurance disputes are strictly breach of contract cases. Missouri courts rarely allow damages for emotional distress in standard contract or vexatious refusal claims, limiting recovery to financial losses and statutory penalties.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!