Illegal Dealer Fees and Contract Packing Scams in New Hampshire Auto Sales
Contract packing and deceptive pricing are illegal in New Hampshire. If a dealer inflates your final contract with mandatory VIN etching or fake bank fees, they are violating N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 358-A:2, and you can demand a refund or sue for damages.
Buying a car in Portsmouth, Keene, or Salem should be a transparent transaction. You negotiate a price, calculate the taxes, and sign the paperwork. However, some unethical auto dealers use a deceptive tactic known as 'contract packing.' This happens when the finance manager sneaks hidden fees, mandatory add-ons, or phantom charges into the final Retail Installment Sales Contract without your clear consent. These scams can inflate the cost of your vehicle by thousands of dollars. Understanding New Hampshire's consumer protection statutes is your best defense against dealer fraud.
The Step-by-Step Process to Fight Dealer Fraud in NH
If you get home and realize your loan balance is thousands of dollars higher than the agreed-upon price, do not assume you are stuck. You have legal recourse to strip those illegal fees from your contract.
Step 1: Identify Mandatory VIN Etching Scams
A common packing trick is 'VIN etching,' where the dealer etches the Vehicle Identification Number onto the windows and charges $300 to $900 for it. They often tell consumers that this is 'mandatory by state law' or that 'it comes on all our cars.' This is a lie. New Hampshire law does not require you to buy VIN etching. If the dealer forces this product on you by claiming it is mandatory, it constitutes a deceptive business practice. Consumers are advised to review their itemized buyer's order carefully to spot this charge.
Step 2: Spot Forced Extended Warranties Disguised as Bank Requirements
Perhaps the most expensive packing scam involves extended warranties, service contracts, or GAP insurance. The finance manager might tell you, 'The bank requires you to buy this extended warranty to get approved for this interest rate.' This is known as 'tied selling' and is illegal under federal and state law. Banks do not require extended warranties for loan approval. If you were lied to, a consumer protection attorney can often force the dealer to cancel the warranty and apply the balance to your principal loan.
Step 3: Challenge Phantom Nitrogen Tire Charges
Another prevalent scam is charging a $100 to $200 'Nitrogen Fee' for putting nitrogen in the tires, or a 'Prep Fee' that was never disclosed in the advertised price. Under New Hampshire law, the advertised price of a vehicle must include all mandatory fees, except for standard state taxes and reasonable title/document fees. Charging for phantom services that provide zero actual value is a classic violation of the state's unfair trade practices.
Step 4: File a Formal Complaint and Demand a Refund
To resolve the issue, a buyer may submit a formal written demand to the dealership's general manager outlining the specific deceptive practices. If the dealer refuses to revise the agreement or issue a refund, the consumer can file Form Consumer Complaint, New Hampshire, Department of Justice, Consumer Complaint Form with the New Hampshire Department of Justice, Consumer Protection and Antitrust Bureau, Concord. State courts take these violations seriously. In cases of blatant deception, precedents like Gautschi v. Auto Body Discount Center, Inc., 139 N.H. 457 (NH Supreme Court 1995) illustrate that New Hampshire courts will penalize businesses that engage in unfair and deceptive acts, often awarding damages to the consumer.
How Much Does it Cost to Sue a Dealer?
Many victims of contract packing hesitate to seek legal help because they fear attorney's fees will cost more than the fake warranties themselves. However, N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 358-A:10 specifically allows a prevailing consumer to recover their legal costs and attorney's fees from the fraudulent dealer. Because of this fee-shifting statute, many skilled attorneys in our directory will review your sales contract for a low flat fee (around $150 to $300) and may take the litigation on a contingency basis if the fraud is blatant.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Dealers know when they have been caught. Often, a certified demand letter from an attorney will result in a refund or contract correction within 14 to 30 days, as the dealer wants to avoid a state investigation. If the dealer is stubborn and forces you to file a lawsuit in an NH Superior Court, the litigation process can take 8 to 14 months to reach a settlement or trial verdict.
Consumers must also remain aware of the applicable statute of limitations. Under N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 358-A:3, IV-a, legal action under the New Hampshire Consumer Protection Act must be commenced within three years from the time the consumer knew, or reasonably should have known, of the deceptive practice.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the legal limit for a 'Doc Fee' in New Hampshire?
Unlike some states that strictly cap documentation fees at a low dollar amount, New Hampshire does not have a strict statutory cap. However, the fee must be reasonable, clearly disclosed on the window sticker or advertised price, and applied equally to all customers to avoid being deemed deceptive.
Can I cancel an extended warranty after I sign the contract?
Yes. Most extended warranties and service contracts have a 30-day or 60-day cancellation provision in the fine print. You can usually cancel it directly with the warranty administrator, and the refund will be sent to your lender to reduce your loan balance.
Is it illegal for a dealer to advertise one price but charge another?
Absolutely. 'Bait and switch' advertising violates both Section 5 of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45, and the New Hampshire Consumer Protection Act, N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 358-A:2. The dealer cannot lure you in with a low internet price and then claim that price only applies if you qualify for obscure rebates or buy their add-ons.
Can I just return the car if I was scammed?
New Hampshire does not provide a general statutory 'cooling-off' period or a 3-day right to cancel a vehicle purchase executed at a dealership. Once the contract is signed and the vehicle leaves the lot, ownership transfers. Consumers generally utilize legal remedies to dispute and remove fraudulent fees rather than attempting to return the vehicle unilaterally.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!