Attorney Fees and Costs in New Jersey Lemon Law Claims: The Fee-Shifting Provision
Under the New Jersey Lemon Law, if your defective car qualifies for a claim, the manufacturer is legally required to pay your attorney fees and court costs. This powerful fee-shifting provision means you can hire an experienced local lawyer with zero out-of-pocket expenses.
Understanding the Fee-Shifting Provision in New Jersey
The most common fear for car owners facing a defective vehicle is the cost of taking on a massive auto manufacturer. Consumers in Newark, Jersey City, and Trenton often worry that hiring a lawyer will cost more than the vehicle is worth. Fortunately, the New Jersey Lemon Law includes a mandatory 'fee-shifting' provision. Under N.J. Stat. § 56:12-42, if a consumer prevails in a Lemon Law case, the manufacturer must pay the consumer's reasonable attorney fees and costs. This levels the playing field, allowing everyday drivers to afford top-tier legal representation without paying hourly rates out of pocket.
Step-by-Step Process for Handling Lemon Law Costs
The process of retaining a lawyer and securing fee-shifting protections requires understanding how state and federal laws work together to protect your wallet. Here is how attorney fees are typically handled from the moment you decide to pursue a claim.
Step 1: Zero Out-of-Pocket Costs for Clients
When you consult a New Jersey Lemon Law attorney, they will generally evaluate your repair orders and dealership invoices for free. If they accept your case, they do so on a contingency-fee or statutory-fee basis. This means you do not pay a retainer fee upfront. The attorney's payment is strictly tied to forcing the manufacturer-such as Ford, General Motors, or Toyota-to pay the legal bill when the case resolves successfully.
Step 2: The 15 U.S.C. § 2310(d)(2) Protection
Even if your case does not strictly qualify under the specific mileage limits of the New Jersey state law, you may still be protected by the federal 15 U.S.C. § 2310(d)(2). This federal law applies to consumer products, including cars, and contains a similar fee-shifting rule. If the manufacturer breaches its written warranty, they are responsible for your attorney fees. This dual layer of state and federal protection makes it highly favorable for consumers to seek legal help.
Step 3: What Happens to Legal Fees in Pre-Trial Settlements
Over 90% of Lemon Law cases settle before ever seeing a courtroom. If the manufacturer agrees to buy back your car or offer a cash settlement, they must also negotiate the payment of your attorney fees. A settlement agreement will typically include a distinct line item where the manufacturer pays the attorney directly, keeping your settlement funds intact. The precedent set in Warrington v. Village Supermarket, Inc., 328 N.J. Super. 410 (NJ App. Div. 2000) strongly supports the recovery of these fees even when cases settle favorably for the consumer.
Step 4: Court Awards vs. Settlement Agreements
If the manufacturer refuses to settle and you must file a lawsuit in a court like the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Essex County, Newark, the judge will issue a formal fee award if you win at trial. The judge reviews the attorney's hourly rate and the time spent on the case to ensure the manufacturer pays a fair and reasonable amount. This ensures that the manufacturer cannot drain you financially by dragging out the litigation.
Step 5: Why You Should Never Use a 'Discount' Lawyer
Because the manufacturer is footing the bill, there is absolutely no reason to hire a 'discount' lawyer or attempt to handle the case yourself through the New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs, Lemon Law Unit, Newark without representation. Hiring an aggressive, highly experienced lawyer costs you the same as hiring a novice: nothing. You deserve to leverage the fee-shifting statute to hire the best possible advocate from our directory.
How Much Does a Lemon Law Claim Cost in New Jersey?
For a consumer with a valid claim, the cost should be entirely minimal.
- Attorney Fees: $0 out-of-pocket for you. The manufacturer pays the lawyer upon successful settlement or verdict.
- Filing Fees: Sometimes the lawyer advances court filing fees (around $250) and recovers them from the manufacturer later.
- State Application Fee: If you file through the state's dispute resolution program, there is a nominal $50 filing fee, which is refunded if you win.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Pre-litigation settlements can often be negotiated within 30 to 90 days of sending a formal demand letter to the manufacturer. However, if the automaker disputes the severity of the defect and forces the case into the civil court system, a lawsuit can take 9 to 18 months to reach a trial or final resolution in New Jersey.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What happens if I lose my Lemon Law case? Do I pay the fees?
Generally, if you hire an attorney on a statutory fee agreement, you are not responsible for their hourly fees if you lose. However, you should carefully read your retainer agreement, as some lawyers may require you to cover minor administrative costs like postage or filing fees.
Does the manufacturer pay my fees if I accept a cash-and-keep settlement?
Yes. If you choose to keep the car and receive a cash settlement for the diminished value of the vehicle, the manufacturer is still legally obligated to pay your attorney's fees separate from your cash award.
Can the manufacturer refuse to pay my lawyer?
They can attempt to dispute the amount of the fees in court, claiming the lawyer charged too much. However, if the court rules that the car is a lemon, the judge will issue a binding order forcing the manufacturer to pay reasonable fees.
Are used cars covered by the fee-shifting provision?
If the used car was still covered by the manufacturer's original factory warranty, you may still be entitled to fee-shifting under the 15 U.S.C. § 2310(d)(2), even if it falls outside the strict New Jersey state new car lemon law.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!