New Jersey Wrongful Death vs. Survival Action: Understanding the Key Differences
In New Jersey, a Wrongful Death claim compensates surviving family members for lost financial support, while a Survival Action compensates the deceased person's estate for the pain and suffering they experienced before dying. You can file both claims simultaneously at the local Superior Court.
Losing a loved one because of someone else's negligence is a devastating experience. While you are grieving, the last thing you want to worry about is navigating the complex legal system. However, securing your family's financial future is a necessary step. In New Jersey, the law allows you to hold the responsible parties accountable, but you must understand that the state treats the loss of life under two separate legal concepts: Wrongful Death and Survival Actions.
Whether you live in Newark, Jersey City, or Cherry Hill, the local courts require you to specifically plead your damages under the correct statutes. While these two claims are almost always filed together in the same lawsuit, they serve entirely different purposes and distribute money to different people. If you find this legal distinction overwhelming, you can search our US Lawyers Directory to find a compassionate local attorney to guide you through the process.
Understanding the New Jersey Wrongful Death Act
The N.J.S.A. § 2A:31-1, was created to help surviving family members who depended on the deceased person for financial support. This claim is forward-looking. It asks the court to calculate what the deceased person would have provided to their family if they had lived a full, natural life.
Damages under this act are strictly limited to "pecuniary" (financial) losses. You can recover money for lost wages, lost benefits (like health insurance or pensions), and the monetary value of lost household services, such as childcare, cleaning, or home maintenance. You can also recover funeral and burial expenses. However, New Jersey law strictly forbids families from claiming damages for their own emotional grief or sorrow under this specific statute.
What is a New Jersey Survival Action?
On the other hand, the N.J.S.A. § 2A:15-3, is backward-looking. It focuses entirely on what the deceased person experienced from the moment they were injured until the exact moment they died. Essentially, the lawsuit "survives" the person's death. If the person had survived the accident, they would have filed a personal injury lawsuit; because they passed away, their estate files it for them.
Calculating Conscious Pain and Suffering Before Death
The most crucial element of a Survival Action is proving "conscious pain and suffering." To recover these damages, the victim must have survived the initial injury for at least a brief period and been consciously aware of their pain. If a person is killed instantly in a car crash, there is typically no conscious pain and suffering, and therefore, a Survival Action may not yield significant damages in that specific category.
However, if the victim was treated in a hospital for days, weeks, or months before passing, the estate can recover massive damages for that agonizing period. In Smith v. Whitaker, 160 N.J. 221 (NJ Supreme Court 1999), the New Jersey Supreme Court highlighted that punitive damages can also be awarded in a Survival Action to punish the wrongdoer, even though punitive damages are generally not allowed in a Wrongful Death claim.
Who Legally Receives the Survival Action Payout?
This is where the two claims differ the most. In a Wrongful Death claim, the settlement money is distributed directly to the victim's dependents (usually a spouse and young children) according to their level of financial reliance. This money is completely protected from the deceased person's creditors.
In a Survival Action, the settlement money goes directly into the deceased person's general Estate. Once there, it becomes subject to estate taxes, and any outstanding debts or medical bills the deceased owed must be paid off first. Only after creditors are satisfied will the remaining money be distributed to the heirs according to the deceased person's Last Will and Testament (or state intestacy laws if there was no will).
How to File Both Claims Simultaneously in NJ Courts
To maximize your recovery, your lawyer will almost always combine both claims into a single Civil Complaint. You will file this paperwork at the Civil Division of your county's Superior Court. For example, if the accident happened in Mercer County, you would file at the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Trenton, submitting the mandatory Form CN 10517, New Jersey, Superior Court, Civil Case Information Statement.
During the trial or settlement negotiations, the jury or the insurance company will be asked to assign specific dollar amounts to the Wrongful Death portion and the Survival Action portion. Having a skilled lawyer is critical here, as allocating more money to the Wrongful Death claim can legally shield those funds from the deceased's outstanding medical debts.
How Much Does it Cost to File in New Jersey?
Filing a complex civil lawsuit involves several fees, but you rarely have to pay out of pocket initially:
- Court Filing Fees: The standard fee to file a Civil Complaint in the New Jersey Superior Court is $250.
- Lawyer Fees: Almost all wrongful death attorneys in New Jersey work on a contingency fee basis. This means they charge nothing upfront. If they win your case, they take a percentage of the settlement (typically 33.3% under New Jersey court rules, depending on the settlement amount).
- Expert Witness Fees: Proving lost future wages and conscious pain requires economic and medical experts. These experts can cost between $5,000 and $15,000 to draft reports and testify, which your attorney usually advances on your behalf.
How Long Does the Legal Process Take?
Wrongful death and survival actions are highly complex and rarely settle overnight. If the insurance company quickly accepts liability, a settlement might be reached in 9 to 12 months. However, if liability is heavily disputed or if medical malpractice is involved, the discovery process and trial can drag on for 2 to 4 years in the New Jersey court system.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I file just a Wrongful Death claim and skip the Survival Action?
Yes, you can file one without the other. If the deceased passed away instantly and left behind no medical bills or pain and suffering damages, your attorney may advise you to solely pursue a Wrongful Death claim to protect the financial recovery for the dependents.
Are the settlement payouts taxable in New Jersey?
Generally, compensation received for personal physical injuries or physical sickness, including wrongful death settlements, is not subject to federal or New Jersey state income tax. However, any portion of the settlement specifically designated as punitive damages is fully taxable.
What if the deceased was partially at fault for the accident?
New Jersey follows a modified comparative negligence rule under N.J.S.A. § 2A:15-5.1. As long as the deceased person was 50% or less at fault, you can still recover damages, but the final payout will be reduced by their exact percentage of fault. If they were 51% or more at fault, the claim is barred.
Can parents file a wrongful death claim for a child?
Yes. If an unmarried child with no dependents passes away, their parents are typically the primary beneficiaries. However, because children usually do not provide financial support to their parents, the pecuniary damages may be limited strictly to the "loss of companionship and advice" that has a measurable economic value, alongside funeral costs.
Will the at-fault driver go to jail if I win a wrongful death civil lawsuit?
No. A wrongful death lawsuit is a civil action handled in the civil courts, and its only outcome is financial compensation. Only the county prosecutor can bring criminal charges (like vehicular manslaughter), which would be handled in a separate criminal court proceeding.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!