What to Do If Someone Files a Fraudulent Tax Return in Rhode Island Under Your SSN
If a scammer files a false tax return using your Social Security Number in Rhode Island, you must immediately secure your identity. Submitting Form 14039, FED, IRS, Identity Theft Affidavit is the critical first step to stopping the fraud and protecting your federal and state tax refunds.
Navigating Tax Identity Theft in Rhode Island
Tax identity theft is a devastating crime. It usually happens when a scammer uses your stolen Social Security Number (SSN) to file a fake tax return early in the year, pocketing your refund before you even realize what happened. You usually find out when you try to file your actual return and the system rejects it. In Rhode Island, this fraud can affect both your federal IRS return and your state taxes. Resolving this mess requires patience and exact paperwork. Finding a skilled tax attorney in our directory can help you communicate with aggressive tax agencies and prove your true identity.
Step-by-Step Process in Rhode Island
Dealing with tax fraud means fighting on two fronts: the federal government and the state of Rhode Island. Here is the step-by-step process to recover your financial identity.
Step 1: Submitting IRS Form 14039 Identity Theft Affidavit
As soon as you discover the fraud, you must alert the federal government. You need to complete Form 14039, FED, IRS, Identity Theft Affidavit. This form officially flags your SSN as compromised. Because the scammers filed electronically, you will likely have to print out your legitimate federal tax return, attach the Form 14039 and copies of your ID, and mail it physically to the IRS. You may also need to visit the Internal Revenue Service, Providence field office to verify your identity in person.
Step 2: Recovering Stolen RI State Tax Refunds
If they stole your federal refund, they likely filed a fraudulent Form RI-1040, Rhode Island, Division of Taxation, Resident Income Tax Return to steal your state refund as well. Tax crimes are severely punished under R.I. Gen. Laws § 44-30-94. You must contact the Rhode Island Division of Taxation, Providence immediately. The state has its own fraud unit, and you will need to provide them with a copy of your police report and your federal Form 14039 to prove that the first return they received was fake, allowing them to manually process your true state return.
Step 3: How 1099 Independent Contractors Can Protect Their EINs
If you run a small business in Warwick or Cranston, scammers might steal your Employer Identification Number (EIN) instead of your SSN. They use the EIN to create fake W-2s or file fraudulent business returns. Independent contractors must be highly protective of their tax numbers. Federal laws like 26 U.S.C. § 7206 deal strictly with false statements on tax documents. If your business identity is stolen, your lawyer will help you file a specialized business identity theft affidavit to secure your company's tax accounts.
Step 4: Resolving False W-2 Income Reported Under Your SSN
Sometimes, tax identity theft is not about stealing a refund. Instead, an undocumented worker or someone dodging child support might use your SSN to get a job. When tax season arrives, the IRS will think you made $50,000 more than you actually did, and they will send you a massive tax bill. Precedents like United States v. Boulerice, 325 F.3d 75 (1st Cir. 2003) illustrate how federal courts handle complex tax fraud and false income reporting. Your attorney will need to dispute this phantom income with both the IRS and the Rhode Island Division of Taxation by proving you never worked for that specific employer.
Federal vs. State Identity Theft Actions
| Action Item | Federal (IRS) | State (RI Division of Taxation) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Form | Form 14039 | Written statement & copy of 14039 |
| Identity PIN | Issues a 6-digit IP PIN for future years | Uses IRS PIN and enhanced screening |
| Filing Method | Must mail paper return | Must mail paper return |
How Much Does it Cost in Rhode Island?
Victims of tax identity theft generally do not have to pay the stolen money back, but the recovery process has associated costs:
- Agency Fees: The IRS and Rhode Island Division of Taxation do not charge fees to process fraud affidavits.
- CPA/Tax Preparer Fees: Hiring a professional to properly prepare and manually mail your true tax returns often costs $300 to $800.
- Tax Lawyer Fees: If the IRS audits you or aggressively pursues you for taxes on income you never earned, hiring a tax attorney can range from $2,500 to $7,500.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Patience is absolutely required. Once you mail your paper returns and identity theft affidavits, your tax processing is frozen. For Rhode Island state returns, resolving the fraud and getting your actual refund usually takes 3 to 6 months. The IRS, however, is notoriously slow with identity theft cases. It generally takes 120 to 180 days (4 to 6 months), but complex federal cases can sometimes take up to a full year before you receive your legitimate tax refund.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Will I eventually get my actual tax refund?
Yes. Once the IRS and the Rhode Island Division of Taxation verify your identity and confirm that the first return was fraudulent, they will process your legitimate return and issue your rightful refund.
How can I prevent this from happening next year?
The best prevention is requesting an Identity Protection PIN (IP PIN) from the IRS. This is a 6-digit number that changes every year. No one can file a federal return under your SSN without knowing this PIN.
Should I close my bank accounts?
If the scammers somehow used your actual bank routing numbers to pull money or deposit fraudulent funds, yes. Otherwise, simply stealing your SSN does not automatically give them access to your checking account.
Can the IRS penalize me for filing late because of fraud?
Generally, no. If you can prove your return was delayed because a scammer locked your SSN by filing a fraudulent return first, the IRS will usually waive any late filing penalties.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!