Understanding Plea in Abeyance Agreements in Utah Criminal Courts
To avoid a permanent criminal conviction on your record in Utah, you may qualify for a Plea in Abeyance (PIA). Under this agreement, the judge pauses your guilty plea, and if you successfully complete probation and pay your fines, the criminal charge is completely dismissed.
Facing criminal charges in Utah can be a terrifying experience. A conviction can ruin your career, housing prospects, and personal reputation. Fortunately, Utah law offers a powerful second chance for many first-time offenders known as a Plea in Abeyance (PIA). Whether you are dealing with a shoplifting charge in Salt Lake City, a minor drug offense in Provo, or a disorderly conduct ticket in Ogden, a PIA allows you to keep your criminal record clean. However, understanding exactly how this agreement works, and the harsh penalties if you fail to meet its terms, is critical. We highly recommend connecting with a local defense lawyer from our directory to negotiate these terms on your behalf.
How Does a Plea in Abeyance Work?
Under Utah Code § 77-2a-1, a Plea in Abeyance is an agreement between you, the prosecutor, and the judge. You agree to plead guilty (or no contest) to the charges, but the judge agrees not to "enter" the conviction on your record. Instead, the plea is held "in abeyance" (paused) for a set period, usually 6 to 18 months. During this time, you must complete specific conditions, such as paying a court fee, taking a class, or avoiding further arrests. If you succeed, the case is dismissed. The Utah Supreme Court has noted in cases like Meza v. State, 359 P.3d 592 (UT Supreme Court 2015) that a successfully completed PIA does not function as a final conviction for most state purposes.
How a PIA Affects CDL Drivers
If you hold a Commercial Driver's License (CDL), a Plea in Abeyance is extremely dangerous, especially for traffic violations. Federal "anti-masking" laws prohibit states from hiding or dismissing traffic convictions for CDL holders. Even if a Utah justice court grants you a PIA, the federal government and the Utah Driver License Division, Salt Lake City will generally still treat the abeyance as a conviction on your driving record. This can lead to the suspension of your commercial privileges. CDL drivers should consult an attorney before ever signing a PIA for a moving violation.
Implications for Professional Licenses
Professionals regulated by the Utah Division of Occupational and Professional Licensing, Salt Lake City (DOPL) must be cautious. Nurses, real estate agents, and contractors often wonder if they must report a PIA. Because a PIA involves a guilty plea, DOPL often requires you to report the agreement immediately, even before it is dismissed. A lawyer can help you draft a statement to the licensing board explaining that the charge is being resolved via an abeyance, protecting your professional livelihood.
The Strict Consequences of Violating the Terms
A PIA is a strict contract. If you miss a payment, fail a drug test, or get a new criminal charge, the prosecutor can file an Order to Show Cause. Because you already pleaded guilty at the beginning of the agreement, you do not get a trial. The judge simply accepts your paused guilty plea, enters the conviction on your permanent record, and sentences you to jail or maximum fines. You lose your chance to fight the case.
Step-by-Step Process to Secure a PIA in Utah
Obtaining this favorable outcome is not automatic; it must be carefully negotiated. Here is how the process generally unfolds in courts like the Third District Court, Salt Lake City or the Fourth District Court, Provo.
Step 1: Determine Your Eligibility
Not all charges qualify. Violent felonies and certain domestic violence or DUI offenses are legally restricted from PIA agreements. Your attorney will review your criminal history to ensure you are a good candidate for this diversion program.
Step 2: Negotiate with the Prosecutor
Your lawyer will meet with the county or city prosecutor to highlight your clean record, your ties to the community, and any weaknesses in the police evidence. The goal is to convince the state that a PIA is the most just outcome.
Step 3: Sign the Official Agreement
You will review and sign a written contract detailing your probation terms. It is essential to ensure you understand every requirement, from community service hours to therapy mandates, before signing the document in front of the judge.
Step 4: Complete the Conditions
You must flawlessly complete all terms. Keep copies of every receipt, class certificate, and community service log. Submit these to the court clerk precisely as instructed.
Step 5: Final Dismissal and Expungement
Once your probationary period ends, the judge will formally dismiss the case. However, the arrest record still exists. To completely wipe it from background checks, because the statutory 30-day waiting period from the date of arrest or charge under Utah Code § 77-40a-302 has already passed, you can immediately file for an expungement with the Utah Bureau of Criminal Identification, Taylorsville using Form Application for Certificate of Eligibility, Utah, Bureau of Criminal Identification, Application for Certificate of Eligibility upon dismissal.
Court Fees and Legal Costs
While a PIA saves you from a conviction, it is not free.
| Cost Category | Estimated Amount & Details |
|---|---|
| Court Abeyance Fee | Courts usually assess a fee that mirrors the statutory maximum fine for the offense (e.g., up to $1,000 for a Class B Misdemeanor under Utah Code § 76-3-301). |
| Lawyer Fees | Most criminal defense attorneys charge a flat fee ranging from $1,500 to $3,500 to negotiate and secure a PIA. |
| Treatment & Classes | You must pay out-of-pocket for any required substance abuse evaluations or anger management classes, usually $50 to $300. |
Timelines for Successful Completion
The entire process, from your first court date to the final dismissal, takes patience. Misdemeanor PIA terms generally last 6 to 12 months. Felony PIA agreements can stretch from 18 to 36 months. After the dismissal is granted, the expungement process takes an additional 4 to 6 months to completely clear your record through the state agencies.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does a Plea in Abeyance show up on a background check?
Yes. While the case is active, it shows as a pending charge. Even after it is dismissed, the original arrest remains visible to employers until you successfully file for and complete a formal expungement.
Can I get a PIA for a first-time DUI in Utah?
Generally, no. Utah law strictly prohibits Pleas in Abeyance for standard DUI charges. However, an attorney might negotiate to reduce the DUI to an impaired driving charge, which sometimes has more flexible sentencing options.
Do I need to drug test while on a PIA?
It depends on the original charge and the judge's orders. If your charge involved drugs or alcohol, random urinalysis testing is highly likely. Failing a test will violate the agreement.
What happens if I cannot pay the abeyance fee on time?
You must request an extension from the judge before the deadline. Do not simply ignore the payment. If you fail to pay without court permission, the judge will revoke the PIA and enter a conviction.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!