How to Defend Against a Relief from Abuse (RFA) Order in Vermont Family Court
To defeat a Relief from Abuse (RFA) order in Vermont, you must understand that family courts use the lower 'preponderance of the evidence' standard. Defending yourself requires gathering text messages, securing witnesses, and appearing at your final hearing to prevent the temporary ex parte order from becoming permanent.
Being served with a Relief from Abuse (RFA) order is an incredibly shocking and stressful experience. In Vermont, an RFA is a civil order designed to protect victims of domestic violence. However, because the initial temporary orders are often granted based solely on one person's unverified story, the system is sometimes misused during divorces or breakups. While an RFA is technically a civil matter heard in family court, the consequences of a final order feel very much like a criminal conviction. It can result in you being immediately evicted from your own home, stripped of your right to see your children, and forced to surrender your firearms.
If a sheriff or local police officer has handed you a temporary RFA, the clock is ticking. You generally have only a few days to prepare for your final hearing. You must treat this hearing with the utmost seriousness. Ignoring the court date will automatically result in a final order against you by default. In this guide, we will break down the exact civil process of fighting an RFA in Vermont, how to properly introduce evidence like text messages, and why finding a local attorney from our US Lawyers directory is critical to protecting your reputation and your family.
Step-by-Step Defense Process in Vermont
RFA hearings take place in the Vermont Family Division. Depending on where you live, you might be summoned to the Vermont Superior Court, Chittenden Family Division, Burlington or the Vermont Superior Court, Washington Family Division, Barre. The process moves incredibly fast, so preparation must begin immediately.
Step 1: Fighting Emergency Ex Parte Orders
When the person accusing you (the plaintiff) files a Form 400-00150C, Vermont, Vermont Superior Court, Complaint for Relief from Abuse, they usually request an emergency 'ex parte' order. Ex parte means the judge only hears their side of the story. Under 15 V.S.A. § 1104, a judge can grant this temporary order if they believe there is an immediate danger of further abuse. You will not have a chance to defend yourself until the final hearing, which is typically scheduled within 14 days. During this temporary period, you must absolutely obey the order. Do not text, email, or use third parties to contact the plaintiff. A single violation of a temporary RFA is a crime that can lead to your immediate arrest.
Step 2: Understanding the 'Preponderance of the Evidence' Standard
Many defendants mistakenly believe the plaintiff has to prove the abuse 'beyond a reasonable doubt.' That is the standard for criminal court. In a civil RFA hearing, the standard is a 'preponderance of the evidence.' This simply means the judge only has to believe that it is more likely than not (51% likely) that abuse occurred. Because the burden of proof is so low, you cannot just show up and say, 'I didn't do it.' You must present a stronger, more credible counter-narrative. Legal precedents like Raynes v. Rogers, 183 Vt. 513 (VT Supreme Court 2008) establish that the family court judge is the ultimate decider of credibility, meaning your demeanor and preparation matter immensely.
Step 3: Presenting Text Messages as Evidence
Your best defense is often found on your smartphone. Text messages, emails, and voicemails can completely contradict the plaintiff's story. If they claim they were terrified of you on a Tuesday, but sent you loving, amicable text messages on Wednesday, the judge needs to see that. However, you cannot just hand the judge your phone. You must print out the screenshots, ensure the contact information (phone number or email address) is clearly visible, and organize them chronologically. Your attorney will help you authenticate these messages under the Vermont Rules of Evidence so the judge will actually accept them into the court record.
Step 4: The Consequences of a Final RFA on Housing and Child Custody
If the judge rules against you and issues a final RFA order, the collateral damage is massive. Under 15 V.S.A. § 1103, the court can award the plaintiff sole possession of your shared residence, even if your name is on the lease or the mortgage. Furthermore, if you share children, the judge will almost certainly suspend or severely restrict your parent-child contact (custody and visitation), sometimes limiting you to supervised visits. A final RFA can last for a year or more and can be renewed if the plaintiff requests it.
How Much Does it Cost in Vermont?
Defending against an RFA requires immediate legal intervention. While the plaintiff does not have to pay to file the RFA, the defendant will incur costs to build a defense.
| Expense Type | Estimated Cost in Vermont |
|---|---|
| Defense Attorney Retainer | $2,500 to $5,000 (Because RFA hearings are expedited and require immediate work) |
| Subpoena Fees (for witnesses or phone records) | $50 to $150 per subpoena |
| Private Investigator (for gathering alibi evidence) | $500 to $1,500 |
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline for an RFA is heavily compressed compared to other civil cases. After the temporary ex parte order is served on you, the final evidentiary hearing is almost always scheduled within 10 to 14 days. If the hearing cannot be completed in one day, the judge will extend the temporary order until the hearing resumes. If a final order is granted, it typically remains in effect for up to one year, though it can sometimes be ordered for a longer duration depending on the severity of the allegations.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Do I have to move out if my name is on the deed?
Yes. If the family court grants a temporary or final RFA giving the plaintiff possession of the residence, you must leave immediately, regardless of whether you own the home or pay the mortgage. You can only return with a police escort to retrieve personal necessities.
What if the plaintiff invites me over while the RFA is active?
Do not go. The RFA is an order directed at you, not the plaintiff. Even if they invite you over or text you, responding or visiting them is a criminal violation of the order. Only a judge can legally lift or modify the RFA.
Can a final RFA affect my job?
Yes. An RFA becomes part of the public court record. If you work in law enforcement, teaching, healthcare, or any profession that requires security clearances or a clean background check, an active domestic violence restraining order can lead to termination.
Can I bring witnesses to the final hearing?
Yes. You have the right to call witnesses who can testify to the events in question or provide an alibi. However, written letters or affidavits from friends are generally not allowed because they are hearsay. The witness must appear in person or by video to be cross-examined.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!