Overcoming the Adultery Bar to Alimony in Virginia: The Manifest Injustice Exception
In Virginia, proving adultery typically bars a spouse from receiving any alimony. However, the court may grant an exception if denying support would create a manifest injustice, such as leaving a dependent spouse completely destitute.
Understanding the Adultery Bar in Virginia
Divorce is already an emotionally exhausting process, but when adultery is involved in Virginia, the financial stakes become incredibly high. Under Virginia law, a spouse who has committed adultery is generally prohibited from receiving spousal support (alimony). This strict rule is designed to penalize marital misconduct. Whether your divorce is filed in the Fairfax County Circuit Court, Fairfax, or the Richmond City Circuit Court, Richmond, judges strictly apply this bar when the misconduct is proven with clear and convincing evidence.
However, the law recognizes that a blanket ban can sometimes result in extreme cruelty. Because of this, the legislature created a specific exception. Proving this exception requires complex legal strategy and deep knowledge of state statutes. We strongly advise finding an experienced family law attorney through our US Lawyers directory to help you navigate this high-stakes litigation.
The Manifest Injustice Exception Explained
Under Va. Code § 20-107.1, subsection B, the court is permitted to award spousal support to an adulterous spouse if, and only if, denying it would constitute a manifest injustice. The burden of proof to demonstrate this injustice rests entirely on the spouse who committed the adultery. The court will look at the respective degrees of fault and the economic circumstances of both parties.
Severe Economic Disparity and Destitution
The most common way to prove manifest injustice is by showing a devastating financial disparity. For example, if a stay-at-home parent gave up their career for 25 years to raise children and support the family, denying them alimony might leave them reliant on public assistance (welfare), while the other spouse earns a massive corporate salary. Judges in Virginia do not want to see citizens thrown into complete destitution. If the financial ruin of the dependent spouse is overwhelmingly disproportionate to the offense of adultery, a judge might grant the exception, as seen in precedents like Barnes v. Barnes, 16 Va. App. 98 (VA Court of Appeals 1993).
Mutual Fault (When Both Spouses Misbehave)
Another common scenario for the manifest injustice exception is when there is significant dual fault. If the spouse seeking support committed adultery, but the other spouse was physically abusive, emotionally cruel, or also committed adultery, the court weighs these actions against each other. If the provider spouse's misconduct was severe and drove the breakdown of the marriage long before the adultery occurred, the court might rule that it is manifestly unjust to let the provider escape paying support.
Step-by-Step Process in Virginia
Step 1: Filing the Complaint
The divorce process officially begins by filing a formal complaint in a Circuit Court. This document, often drafted by your lawyer, sets the grounds for divorce. The filing spouse will submit the required paperwork, which often includes a general Form VS-4, Virginia, Department of Health, Report of Divorce or Annulment, alongside the specific legal pleadings.
Step 2: The Discovery Phase
During discovery, both sides gather evidence. The spouse alleging adultery must prove it with strict, corroborated evidence (not just a hunch). Meanwhile, the spouse seeking the manifest injustice exception must gather decades of financial records, tax returns, and employability evaluations to prove that they will be destitute without support.
Step 3: The Evidentiary Hearing
Because adultery and manifest injustice are highly contested, the case will likely go to a full trial. Your attorney will call witnesses, present financial affidavits, and cross-examine the other spouse. The judge will listen to all evidence before deciding whether to apply the adultery bar or invoke the exception.
How Much Does This Litigation Cost in Virginia?
Litigating adultery and a manifest injustice exception is highly complex and rarely settled out of court, making it an expensive process. Typical costs in Virginia include:
| Type of Expense | Estimated Cost (USD) |
|---|---|
| Circuit Court Filing Fees | $85 - $150 |
| Private Investigator (to prove/disprove fault) | $1,500 - $5,000 |
| Vocational Expert (to prove destitution) | $2,000 - $4,500 |
| Attorney Fees (Litigated Divorce) | $15,000 - $40,000+ |
How Long Does the Process Take?
In Virginia, you generally must be separated for one year before filing for a standard no-fault divorce, but filing on the fault grounds of adultery allows you to file immediately. However, actually getting to trial for a highly contested manifest injustice case can take anywhere from 12 to 18 months due to backlogs in courts like the Virginia Beach Circuit Court, Virginia Beach.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What proof is required for adultery in Virginia?
Virginia requires clear and convincing evidence of adultery, which is a very high standard. You generally need corroborating evidence from a third party, such as a private investigator, showing the spouse had the disposition and the opportunity to commit the act.
Does emotional cheating trigger the adultery bar?
No. Under Virginia law, adultery strictly requires physical sexual intercourse. Emotional affairs, texting, or kissing do not meet the legal definition of adultery, though they can be considered under general cruelty or fault grounds.
If I am forgiven, can my spouse still use adultery against me?
If your spouse knew about the adultery and willingly resumed living together and having marital relations with you, they may have legally condoned the act. Condonation is a defense against the adultery bar in Virginia.
Can child support be denied because of adultery?
Absolutely not. The adultery bar only applies to spousal support. Child support is the right of the child and is calculated based entirely on state guidelines and the financial needs of the children.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!