How to File a Defective Medical Device Lawsuit in Wisconsin: Timelines and Costs
If a medical device breaks or causes severe complications in Wisconsin, you can sue the manufacturer for product liability. Because of the 'discovery rule,' your 3-year deadline to file a lawsuit begins when you actually discover the device is defective, not the day it was implanted.
When you undergo surgery to receive a medical implant or rely on a device to keep you breathing at night, you expect it to improve your health. Tragically, multi-billion-dollar medical corporations sometimes rush products to market without adequate safety testing. It is crucial to understand that a defective medical device lawsuit is entirely different from a medical malpractice claim. If a surgeon implants a pacemaker perfectly, but the pacemaker's battery suddenly dies due to a manufacturing defect, the doctor is not at fault. In Wisconsin, your legal action is a strict product liability claim directed solely at the medical device manufacturer under Wis. Stat. § 895.047. You have the right to seek compensation for additional revision surgeries, permanent disability, and severe physical trauma.
Medical Device Liability and the Discovery Rule
Under Wisconsin law, a victim of personal injury generally has three years to file a lawsuit under Wis. Stat. § 893.54. However, with medical devices, you might not know an implant is slowly poisoning you or breaking apart until years after the surgery. Wisconsin protects patients through the "discovery rule" codified in Wis. Stat. § 893.54(1m). This rule dictates that your three-year countdown does not begin until the day you discover, or reasonably should have discovered, that the device was the cause of your injury. The landmark decision in Hansen v. A.H. Robins Co., 113 Wis. 2d 550 (WI Supreme Court 1983) solidified this right, ensuring that manufacturers cannot hide behind the statute of limitations when their internal devices fail years later. Nevertheless, claimants must also account for Wisconsin's 15-year statute of repose under Wis. Stat. § 895.047(5), which generally bars strict product liability claims if more than 15 years have elapsed since the product was manufactured, unless an extended warranty or latent disease exception applies.
Common Defective Medical Device Claims
Defective CPAP Machines (Foam Degradation)
Millions of people rely on CPAP and BiPAP machines for sleep apnea. However, major manufacturer recalls have highlighted a deadly defect: the sound-abating foam inside the machines degrades over time. As the foam breaks down, patients inhale toxic chemical particles and microscopic foam dust directly into their lungs while they sleep. This severe manufacturing and design defect has been directly linked to respiratory failure, asthma, and various forms of lung and kidney cancer.
Faulty Pacemakers
A pacemaker is literally a life-saving device. When a pacemaker has a defective battery seal, faulty wiring, or a software glitch that fails to regulate a heartbeat, the patient is at immediate risk of cardiac arrest. Lawsuits against cardiovascular device makers focus on the manufacturer's failure to warn patients and doctors about these deadly electrical flaws.
Broken IVC Filters
Inferior Vena Cava (IVC) filters are tiny, spider-like metal devices implanted in a patient's major vein to catch blood clots before they reach the lungs. Unfortunately, poor design and weak metal alloys cause many of these filters to fracture inside the body. The broken metal legs travel through the bloodstream, piercing the heart, lungs, and other vital organs, requiring emergency open-heart surgery to extract the shrapnel.
Defective Joint Replacements
Hip and knee replacements are meant to restore mobility. However, certain metal-on-metal hip implants and poorly bonded knee replacements have resulted in catastrophic failure. The friction from defective metal joints sheds microscopic cobalt and chromium shavings into the surrounding tissue, causing a condition called metallosis (metal poisoning). This destroys bone and muscle tissue, forcing the patient to undergo highly painful revision surgeries.
Step-by-Step Process to Sue a Medical Device Manufacturer
Taking on a pharmaceutical or medical device giant is a massive undertaking. You can search our US Lawyers directory to find a highly specialized mass tort and product liability attorney to manage your case.
Step 1: Secure Your Medical Records
Your attorney's first step is to obtain your complete surgical records to identify the exact make, model, and serial number of the device implanted in your body. They will also gather the surgical notes from any revision surgeries detailing how the device failed or fractured.
Step 2: Joining an MDL or Filing Individually
Because thousands of people are often injured by the exact same device, federal courts often group these cases into Multidistrict Litigation (MDL). Your attorney will evaluate whether it is best to file a standalone claim in a state court, such as the Outagamie County Circuit Court, Appleton, or file Form JS 44, FED, U.S. District Court, Civil Cover Sheet to transfer your case into a massive federal MDL.
Step 3: Discovery and Global Settlements
In device litigation, your legal team will demand millions of pages of internal corporate emails to prove the manufacturer knew about the defect but sold the product anyway. Often, after a few "bellwether" trials in federal court, the manufacturer will agree to a global settlement fund to compensate all injured plaintiffs based on the severity of their injuries.
How Much Does it Cost in Wisconsin?
You can hire elite medical device lawyers with zero upfront money. These cases are handled strictly on a contingency fee basis. The law firm covers all federal court filing fees (typically $405) and advances the hundreds of thousands of dollars needed to hire biomedical engineering experts. You only pay a percentage (usually 33% to 40%) of the final settlement if you win. If the lawsuit fails, you owe the attorney nothing.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Defective medical device claims are notoriously slow because you are fighting multi-billion-dollar global corporations. If your case is wrapped into a federal MDL, the process from filing the complaint to receiving a settlement check can easily take 2 to 5 years. Patience is essential, as these cases require exhaustive scientific discovery.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I sue the FDA for approving a defective medical device?
No. The federal government has sovereign immunity and cannot be sued for clearing a medical device. Your lawsuit is strictly against the private corporation that designed, manufactured, and profited from the dangerous product.
What is federal preemption?
Under 21 U.S.C. § 360k, manufacturers of certain highly regulated Class III devices sometimes argue that federal law shields them from state product liability lawsuits. Your attorney must prove the manufacturer violated federal safety requirements to overcome this defense.
Do I need to have the device removed before I can sue?
Not necessarily. While a revision surgery provides physical evidence of the defect, some patients are too old or fragile to survive a second surgery. You can still sue if imaging (like an MRI or X-ray) or blood tests (like heavy metal toxicity panels) prove the device has failed inside you.
Are these cases considered class action lawsuits?
Most defective device lawsuits are not class actions. They are usually handled as Multidistrict Litigation (MDL). In an MDL, your case is grouped with others for pretrial discovery to save time, but your lawsuit remains individual, and your compensation is based entirely on your specific injuries.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!