Christine's Law in Pennsylvania: Traffic Citations and Liability for Snow and Ice on Vehicles
Under Pennsylvania's Christine's Law (75 Pa.C.S. § 3721), drivers must clear snow and ice from their vehicles within 24 hours after a winter storm ends. Failing to do so can result in a $50 fine, and if flying ice causes serious injury or death, penalties can skyrocket to $1,500.
Winter in Pennsylvania brings beautiful snowfalls, but it also brings incredibly dangerous driving conditions. For years, drivers on the Turnpike or I-95 have experienced the terrifying moment when a massive sheet of ice flies off the roof of the vehicle ahead of them, smashing into their windshield. To combat this severe hazard, Pennsylvania passed a comprehensive amendment to the Vehicle Code known as 'Christine's Law,' named in honor of Christine Lambert, a resident who was tragically killed by flying ice in 2005.
The law is strict, and state troopers actively enforce it during the winter months in cities from Erie to Philadelphia. However, because the law provides a specific time window for compliance, many drivers are wrongfully ticketed before their legal grace period has actually expired. If you have been cited for driving with snow on your roof, or if you were injured by ice flying off a commercial truck, understanding the specific mechanics of this statute is crucial. A local traffic defense or personal injury lawyer from our directory can help you navigate the local court systems to protect your rights.
Step-by-Step Process: Fighting a Snow and Ice Citation
If you receive a traffic ticket for failing to clear your vehicle, you have the right to fight it in local court. Here is the standard process for disputing a traffic citation in Pennsylvania.
Step 1: Pleading Not Guilty
When the officer hands you the ticket, do not argue on the side of the road. You generally have 10 days to respond. You must sign the 'Not Guilty' portion of the citation and mail it to the proper local court, along with the required collateral fee. This prevents your license from being suspended for failure to respond.
Step 2: Gathering Meteorological Evidence
Christine's Law explicitly gives drivers a 24-hour grace period after the weather event has ceased. Your strongest defense is proving that it was still actively snowing, or that the snow had stopped less than 24 hours before you were pulled over. Your attorney will gather certified weather reports from the National Weather Service for your specific zip code to establish the exact timeline of the storm.
Step 3: Attending Your Summary Trial
Traffic citations are heard at the Magisterial District level. You and your lawyer will attend a hearing at the local court, such as the Lackawanna County Magisterial District Court, Scranton or the Lehigh County Magisterial District Court, Allentown. During the hearing, your attorney will cross-examine the police officer and present your weather data to prove the citation was issued prematurely.
Commercial Delivery Vans vs. Passenger Cars
The rules apply to everyone, but they are particularly burdensome for the trucking industry. Drivers of 18-wheelers, box trucks, and commercial delivery vans frequently argue that climbing on top of a 13-foot trailer to clear snow is a violation of federal workplace safety rules regarding fall hazards. However, 75 Pa.C.S. § 3721 does not provide a blanket exemption for commercial vehicles. Trucking companies are expected to use specialized snow scrapers, roof rakes, or drive-through snow removal machines at their depots. If a commercial driver fails to clear their roof and causes an accident, both the driver and the trucking company can be held liable for negligence.
Penalties if Flying Ice Causes Property Damage
Christine's Law acts as a primary offense, meaning an officer can pull you over simply for having snow on your roof, even if no ice has fallen off yet. The base fine for this proactive citation is $50. However, the penalties escalate drastically if the ice dislodges and strikes another vehicle or a pedestrian.
If the flying snow or ice causes serious bodily injury or death, the driver faces a fine ranging from $200 to $1,500 under 75 Pa.C.S. § 3721(b). Beyond the traffic fines, causing an accident because of an uncleared roof exposes the driver to severe civil liability. In a personal injury lawsuit, the victim's attorney will use the traffic citation as 'negligence per se'-legal proof that you breached your duty of care to other drivers, making it much easier for the victim to win financial compensation for their smashed windshield or physical injuries.
How to Fight the Ticket if Pulled Over Before the Grace Period Ends
The 24-hour rule is the most heavily litigated aspect of Christine's Law. The statute states that the requirement to clear the vehicle goes into effect 24 hours 'following the cessation of the falling snow, sleet or freezing rain.' If you live in Pittsburgh and a blizzard stops at 8:00 AM on a Tuesday, you legally have until 8:00 AM on Wednesday to clear your car. If a state trooper pulls you over at 6:00 PM on Tuesday evening for having a foot of snow on your roof, the citation is legally invalid because you were still inside the 24-hour grace period. Your lawyer will file a Form AOPC 2026, Pennsylvania, Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts, Notice of Appeal from Summary Criminal Conviction if the local magistrate incorrectly convicts you despite this clear timeline.
How Much Does it Cost in Pennsylvania?
Handling a traffic ticket or an accident claim involves various costs. Here is what you can generally expect:
| Legal Action | Estimated Cost in Pennsylvania |
|---|---|
| Paying the Base Fine (No Injury) | $50, plus state court costs and surcharges (often bringing the total to $100 - $150). |
| Fine for Serious Injury/Death | $200 to $1,500. |
| Hiring a Traffic Attorney | Typically a flat fee ranging from $250 to $750 for a Magisterial District Court hearing. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
If you choose to fight your snow and ice ticket, the local Magisterial District Court will usually schedule your summary trial within 30 to 60 days of receiving your 'Not Guilty' plea. If you lose and decide to appeal the decision to the County Court of Common Pleas, that secondary process can take an additional 3 to 6 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does Christine's Law apply to out-of-state drivers?
Yes. Any vehicle traveling on Pennsylvania public roads must comply with the state's Vehicle Code, regardless of where the car is registered.
What if I am physically unable to reach the roof of my SUV?
The law does not provide an exemption for height or physical ability. You are required to use long-handled snow brooms or seek assistance before driving on public highways.
Can a police officer pull me over just for the snow?
Yes. The 2022 amendment made this a primary offense, meaning the police do not need another reason (like speeding or a broken taillight) to initiate the traffic stop.
What if the snow on my car is only a light dusting?
The law targets accumulations that pose a threat to people or property. While a light dusting is rarely cited, thick sheets of heavy, wet snow or solid ice are the primary targets for enforcement.
Will this ticket add points to my PA driver's license?
Generally, a standard citation for failing to clear snow under this specific statute does not carry PennDOT points, but it does carry significant fines and creates a public record.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!