Profile
Aggressive Advocates for the Injured
McCoy & Hiestand, PLC is a dynamic and results-driven personal injury law firm located in the heart of St. Matthews, Louisville. Founded by attorneys Sheila Hiestand and Gary McCoy, the firm has quickly established itself as a force to be reckoned with in the Kentucky legal landscape. The firm's philosophy is built on a combination of aggressive litigation tactics and compassionate client care. They brand themselves as 'The Law Tigers,' symbolizing their fierce dedication to fighting for their clients' rights against negligent parties and stubborn insurance carriers. With over 50 years of combined legal experience, the team at McCoy & Hiestand understands that a serious injury can turn a person's life upside down, and they are committed to restoring order and financial stability to their clients' lives.
Comprehensive Personal Injury Practice
The firm handles a wide array of personal injury matters, bringing the same level of intensity and preparation to every case, regardless of its size. Their primary practice areas include:
- Car and Motorcycle Accidents: The firm has a particular strength in representing victims of motor vehicle accidents. They work with accident reconstruction experts to prove liability and ensure clients are compensated for medical bills, future care needs, and lost income.
- Trucking Accidents: aggressively pursuing claims against trucking companies for accidents caused by driver fatigue, overloading, or maintenance failures.
- Premises Liability: Representing individuals injured in slip and fall accidents, dog bites, or due to inadequate security on commercial properties.
- Nursing Home Abuse: A dedicated focus on protecting the elderly from neglect and abuse in care facilities, fighting for dignity and justice for the most vulnerable.
- Wrongful Death: Standing beside families who have lost loved ones, pursuing accountability and compensation for their tragic loss.
Client-Centric Fee Structure
McCoy & Hiestand, PLC believes that high-quality legal representation should be accessible to everyone, regardless of their financial status. To this end, they operate on a strict contingency fee basis. This means clients pay zero attorney fees unless the firm wins the case. There are no retainers and no hourly billing. This 'No Win, No Fee' promise allows injury victims to hire top-tier legal talent without the stress of upfront costs. The firm also provides free initial case evaluations, allowing potential clients to get professional legal advice and understand the viability of their claims at no cost.
Award-Winning Legal Team
The attorneys at McCoy & Hiestand are widely recognized for their professional achievements. They have been honored by Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers in America, and other prestigious legal directories. Sheila Hiestand is known for her trial skills and her leadership in the legal community. The firm's success is not just measured in awards, but in the millions of dollars they have recovered for their clients. Their approach is personal: they take the time to get to know their clients, understanding the full impact of the injury on their daily lives, which allows them to tell a more compelling story to a jury or insurance adjuster.
We treat you like family, and we fight for you like tigers. Our job is to handle the legal battle so you can focus on healing.
Convenient St. Matthews Location
The firm's office is strategically located on Browns Lane in St. Matthews, one of Louisville's most accessible and vibrant neighborhoods. This central location makes it easy for clients from all over the city to visit. The office environment is warm and welcoming, designed to put clients at ease during stressful times. The team is known for being responsive and accessible, ensuring that clients are never left in the dark about the status of their case. Whether you have been injured in a traffic accident or hurt on someone else's property, McCoy & Hiestand, PLC has the experience, the resources, and the fighting spirit to secure the justice you deserve.
Don't let an insurance company dictate the value of your life and health. Contact McCoy & Hiestand, PLC today for a free consultation and let the Law Tigers fight for you.
Specializing In
Car Accidents, Slip and Fall, Nursing Home Abuse, Motorcycle Accidents
Address & Location
McCoy & Hiestand, PLC is located at 108 Browns Lane. The office is situated in the bustling St. Matthews area, directly across the street from the Mall St. Matthews.
Building Location
The firm is housed in a professional, standalone single-story building. It is easily visible from Browns Lane and is located just a few blocks from Shelbyville Road and close to Baptist Health Louisville hospital.
Suite Access
Entrance to the office is at street level through the main front door. The facility is fully handicap accessible with no steps required for entry.
Parking Details
Clients enjoy the convenience of a private parking lot located immediately next to the building. Free parking is always available for visitors.
Public Transit
The office is well-served by public transit. TARC Route 19 (Muhammad Ali) and Route 31 (Shelbyville Road) have stops within a very short walking distance along Shelbyville Road and Browns Lane.
Map
Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.
Sorry, unable to load the Maps API.



